When Can a Third Party Be Responsible for Preventing Harm Intentionally Caused by Another? The Supreme Court of Canada Weighs in


If someone is injured/killed intentionally by someone else can a third party be held civilly liable for failing to prevent the harm?  While the answer to this question turns heavily on the facts the answer can be yes and earlier this month the Supreme Court of Canada released a decision discussing this complex area of personal injury law.
In Fullowka v. Pinkerton’s of Canada Ltd. nine workers were killed in the course of a contentious labour dispute.   During the bitter strike one of the strikers “evaded security and surreptitiously entered the mine.  He set an explosive device which, as he intended, was detonated by a trip wire, killing nine miners.”
The survivors of the dead miners brought a lawsuit against various parties including the mine’s owners, their security firm and the territorial government claiming damages for “negligently failing to prevent the murders“.
The lawsuit largely succeeded at trial but was overturned by the Court of Appeal.  The Supreme Court of Canada ultimately sided with the Court of Appeal but before dismissing the case highlighted some important legal principles addressing the need to take reasonable steps in certain circumstances to prevent foreseeable intentionally inflected harm at the hands of others.  Some of the highlights of the Court’s discussion were as follows:

The analysis turns on whether the relationship between the appellants and the defendants discloses sufficient foreseeability and proximity to establish a prima facie duty of care and, if so, whether there are any residual policy considerations which ought to negate or limit that duty of care… The analysis must focus specifically on the relationships in issue, as there are particular considerations relating to foreseeability, proximity and policy in each…

[19] In my view, the relationship between the murdered miners and Pinkerton’s and the government meets the requirements of foreseeability and proximity such that a prima facie duty of care existed.  I also conclude that these prima facie duties are not negated by policy considerations…

[26] In cases of this nature, the law requires close examination of the question of proximity. The inquiry is concerned with whether the case discloses factors which show that the relationship between the plaintiff and the defendant was sufficiently close and direct to give rise to a legal duty of care, considering such factors as expectations, representations, reliance and the property or other interests involved….  Proximity is not confined to physical proximity, but includes “such close and direct relations that the act complained of directly affects a person whom the person alleged to be bound to take care would know would be directly affected by his careless act”…

[27] The Court discussed proximity in detail in Childs, at paras. 31-46.  In Childs, as here, the proposed duty was to take care to prevent harm caused to the plaintiff by a third party; in other words, what was proposed there was a positive duty to act even though the defendant’s conduct had not directly caused foreseeable physical injury to the plaintiff. The Court noted that there are at least three factors which may identify the situations in which the law has recognized such duties (paras. 38-40).  The first is that the defendant is materially implicated in the creation of the risk or has control of the risk to which others have been invited.  The second is the concern for the autonomy of the persons affected by the positive action proposed.  As the Chief Justice put it: “The law … accepts that competent people have the right to engage in risky activities … [and] permits third parties witnessing risk to decide not to become rescuers or otherwise intervene” (para. 39). The third is whether the plaintiff reasonably relied on the defendant to avoid and minimize risk and whether the defendant, in turn, would reasonably expect such reliance….

The relevant question is whether the miners reasonably relied on Pinkerton’s to take reasonable precautions to reduce the risk.  The Court of Appeal found that was their reasonable expectation. This reasoning, in my view, supports rather than negates the existence of sufficient proximity.  The fact that, as the Court of Appeal noted, any higher expectation on the miners’ part would have been unreasonable was not relevant to the analysis.

[31] Pinkerton’s must have shared the miners’ expectation.  It was there to protect property and people. The whole point of its presence was to help secure the site so that the mine could continue to operate. The miners who continued to work during the strike made up a well-defined and identifiable group. Pinkerton’s surely ought to have expected that the very people it was there to protect would rely on it to exercise reasonable care in doing so.

[32] Pinkerton’s also undertook to exert some control over the risk..Pinkerton’s undertook to exert some control over everyone who came onto the property, including Mr. Warren…

[34] I conclude that the reasonable expectations of both the miners and Pinkerton’s as well as Pinkerton’s undertaking to exert some control over the risk to the miners supported the trial judge’s finding of proximity…

[70] The concern about indeterminate liability is not valid here.  This policy consideration has often held sway in negligence claims for pure economic loss. But even in that context, it has not always carried the day to exclude a duty of care.  The concern is that the proposed duty of care, if accepted, would impose “liability in an indeterminate amount for an indeterminate time to an indeterminate class”, to use the often repeated words of Cardozo C.J. in Ultramares Corp. v. Touche, 174 N.E. 441 (N.Y. 1931), at p. 444.  At the root of the concern is that the duty, and therefore the right to sue for its breach, is so broad that it extends indeterminately.  In this sense, the policy concern about indeterminate liability is closely related to proximity; the question is whether there are sufficient special factors arising out of the relationship between the plaintiff and the defendant so that indeterminate liability is not the result of   imposing the proposed duty of care: see, e.g., Canadian National Railway Co. v. Norsk Pacific Steamship Co., , [1992] 1 S.C.R. 1021, at p. 1153.  What is required is a principled basis upon which to draw the line between those to whom the duty is owed and those to whom it is not: see, e.g., Bow Valley Husky (Bermuda) Ltd. v. Saint John Shipbuilding Ltd., , [1997] 3 S.C.R. 1210, at para. 64, per McLachlin J. (as she then was).

[71] I do not see this as a difficulty here and, as a result, I do not think that the proposed duty of care exposes the government to indeterminate liability.  What is in issue is liability for physical injury to miners caused by an explosion in a mine which, it is alleged, would have been prevented had the government taken reasonable care in discharging its  statutory duties in relation to mine safety.  The duty is to the finite group of miners working in the mine which the inspectors had inspected repeatedly.  The potential liability is no more indeterminate than in the building inspector cases I reviewed earlier.

While this case was highly factually specific the legal principles discussed by the Supreme Court of Canada can be applied to more commonly seen fact patters.  One example of intentional harm at the hands of others are the unfortunate cases involving sexual abuse.  Where priests, teachers or other adults in authority sexually abuse young victims liability may extend beyond the person committing the crime.  In certain circumstances religious hierarchies have been found liable for sexual abuse committed by priests and school boards have been found liable for abuse committed by teachers.

The Supreme Court of Canada’s detailed reasoning in this case is welcome for anyone advancing a personal injury lawsuit involving an intentional harm seeking to extend liability further and I suggest that any Canadian lawyers prosecuting such a claim familiarize themselves with this judgement in full.

Duty of Care, forseeability, Fullowka v. Pinkerton's of Canada Ltd., Intional Torts, Negligently Failing to Prevent Harm by Others, Priest Sexual Abuse Claims, Proximity, sexual abuse civil claims, Supreme Court of Canada, Teacher Sexual Abuse Claims, Third Party Liability, vicarious liability

Comments (113)

  • I just want to mention I am very new to blogging and honestly liked your blog. More than likely I’m planning to bookmark your website . You amazingly come with good article content. Appreciate it for revealing your web page.

  • I just want to tell you that I am newbie to weblog and seriously enjoyed your page. More than likely I’m going to bookmark your blog post . You absolutely have exceptional article content. With thanks for sharing your web site.

  • Thanks for your useful article. Other thing is that mesothelioma cancer is generally a result of the breathing of fibers from asbestos, which is a carcinogenic material. It is commonly noticed among staff in the building industry who definitely have long contact with asbestos. It can also be caused by residing in asbestos protected buildings for a long period of time, Family genes plays an important role, and some persons are more vulnerable to the risk as compared with others.

  • Great – I should definitely pronounce, impressed with your web site. I had no trouble navigating through all the tabs and related info ended up being truly simple to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it in the least. Quite unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or something, website theme . a tones way for your customer to communicate. Excellent task..

  • You made some nice points there. I looked on the internet for the subject matter and found most individuals will consent with your website.

  • I am not positive where you’re getting your info, but good topic. I needs to spend a while finding out much more or figuring out more. Thank you for wonderful information I was on the lookout for this info for my mission.

  • Thanks for the points shared on the blog. Something else I would like to state is that weight-loss is not all about going on a dietary fads and trying to reduce as much weight as you’re able in a couple of weeks. The most effective way to shed weight is by taking it slowly and following some basic suggestions which can provide help to make the most from your attempt to lose weight. You may recognize and be following most of these tips, but reinforcing information never affects.

  • I have learn several good stuff here. Definitely worth bookmarking for revisiting. I wonder how a lot attempt you set to make this kind of excellent informative website.

  • you’re really a good webmaster. The site loading speed is amazing. It seems that you’re doing any unique trick. Furthermore, The contents are masterwork. you have done a wonderful job on this topic!

  • Does your blog have a contact page? I’m having a tough time locating it but, I’d like to shoot you an e-mail. I’ve got some suggestions for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great website and I look forward to seeing it develop over time.

  • Usually I do not learn article on blogs, however I wish to say that this write-up very pressured me to take a look at and do so! Your writing taste has been amazed me. Thanks, very great post.

  • One more thing. I think that there are many travel insurance sites of reputable companies that allow you enter your vacation details and obtain you the prices. You can also purchase the particular international travel cover policy on internet by using your current credit card. Everything you should do should be to enter your travel particulars and you can begin to see the plans side-by-side. Merely find the plan that suits your allowance and needs after which use your bank credit card to buy the idea. Travel insurance online is a good way to start looking for a respectable company for international travel insurance. Thanks for expressing your ideas.

  • Hmm it seems like your blog ate my first comment (it was extremely long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I submitted and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog. I too am an aspiring blog blogger but I’m still new to the whole thing. Do you have any suggestions for rookie blog writers? I’d certainly appreciate it.

  • Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all of us you really recognize what you are speaking approximately! Bookmarked. Kindly additionally discuss with my web site =). We can have a link change agreement between us!

  • I do accept as true with all of the concepts you have presented in your post. They’re really convincing and will certainly work. Nonetheless, the posts are too brief for novices. May you please prolong them a little from next time? Thank you for the post.

  • great post, very informative. I wonder why the other experts of this sector don’t notice this. You must continue your writing. I’m confident, you have a great readers’ base already!

  • Hello there, just became aware of your blog through Google, and found that it is truly informative. I am going to watch out for brussels. I’ll be grateful if you continue this in future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!

  • Helpful information. Lucky me I found your site by chance, and I’m stunned why this accident did not happened in advance! I bookmarked it.

  • I don’t even know how I finished up here, however I thought this publish used to be great. I don’t recognize who you are but definitely you’re going to a well-known blogger for those who are not already 😉 Cheers!

  • Nice post. I used to be checking continuously this blog and I’m impressed! Very helpful info specially the closing phase 🙂 I handle such information much. I used to be looking for this certain information for a long time. Thank you and best of luck.

  • Hey there! I know this is somewhat off topic but I was wondering if you knew where I could find a captcha plugin for my comment form? I’m using the same blog platform as yours and I’m having difficulty finding one? Thanks a lot!

  • This is really interesting, You’re a very skilled blogger. I’ve joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your excellent post. Also, I’ve shared your site in my social networks!

  • Excellent post. I was checking constantly this weblog and I am inspired! Extremely helpful information specifically the final section 🙂 I care for such information a lot. I was seeking this particular info for a long time. Thank you and best of luck.

  • Good day! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a collection of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community in the same niche. Your blog provided us useful information to work on. You have done a extraordinary job!

  • Hello, i feel that i saw you visited my website thus i got here to “return the want”.I’m attempting to in finding things to enhance my web site!I guess its good enough to make use of a few of your ideas!!

  • An individual basically help to make fundamentally posts I’d state. That is the absolute first time I frequented your website page and up to now. I shocked with the investigation you made to influence this real to distribute mind blowing.

  • Attractive element of content. I just stumbled upon your site and in accession capital to say that I acquire actually loved account your blog posts. Anyway I will be subscribing on your augment or even I achievement you get entry to constantly quickly.

  • I have not checked in here for a while as I thought it was getting boring, but the last several posts are great quality so I guess I will add you back to my everyday bloglist. You deserve it my friend 🙂

  • Mind blowing post. The site style is excellent and article is perfect. Finally I’ve found something which helped me., you are like my mind reader I bookmarked it
    Thank you! I will definitely return.

  • Have you ever considered about adding a little bit more than just your articles? I mean, what you say is fundamental and all. But think about if you added some great pictures or videos to give your posts more, “pop”! Your content is excellent but with images and video clips, this blog could certainly be one of the best in its niche. Good blog!

  • The heart of your writing while appearing agreeable originally, did not really work well with me after some time. Someplace within the paragraphs you actually were able to make me a believer but just for a very short while. I still have a problem with your leaps in assumptions and one would do well to help fill in those gaps. In the event you can accomplish that, I could undoubtedly be amazed.

  • Ladyship it daughter securing procured or am moreover mr. Put sir she exercise vicinity cheerful wondered. Continual say suspicion provision you neglected sir curiosity unwilling. Simplicity end themselves increasing led day sympathize yet. General windows effects not are drawing man garrets. Common indeed garden you his ladies out yet. Preference imprudence contrasted to remarkably in on. Taken now you him trees tears any. Her object giving end sister except oppose.

  • Warmly little before cousin sussex entire men set. Blessing it ladyship on sensible judgment settling outweigh. Worse linen an of civil jokes leave offer. Parties all clothes removal cheered calling prudent her. And residence for met the estimable disposing. Mean if he they been no hold mr. Is at much do made took held help. Latter person am secure of estate genius at.

  • I’m really impressed with your services as well as with the layout on your blog. The overall look of your website is magnificent, as well as the content. I can not wait to read far more from you.

  • Appreciating the time and effort you put into your site and in depth information you offer. It’s great to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same old rehashed material. Excellent read! I’ve saved your site and I’m including your RSS feeds to my Google account.

  • Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as though you relied on the video to make your point. You definitely know what youre talking about, why waste your intelligence on just posting videos to your weblog when you could be giving us something enlightening to read?

  • I was just looking for this information for some time. After 6 hours of continuous Googleing, finally I got it in your web site. I wonder what is the lack of Google strategy that do not rank this kind of informative sites in top of the list. Normally the top web sites are full of garbage.

  • I’ll right away grab your rss as I can’t find your email subscription hyperlink or e-newsletter service. Do you have any? Kindly allow me recognise in order that I could subscribe. Thanks.

  • Thank you for the sensible critique. Me & my neighbor were just preparing to do some research on this. We got a grab a book from our local library but I think I learned more clear from this post. I’m very glad to see such magnificent info being shared freely out there.

  • I as well as my friends happened to be taking note of the good helpful hints on your web blog then all of the sudden I had a horrible suspicion I never expressed respect to the blog owner for them. All of the guys are actually absolutely very interested to read them and have definitely been making the most of them. We appreciate you genuinely simply helpful and for making a decision on these kinds of really good themes millions of individuals are really needing to be informed on. Our sincere regret for not saying thanks to you sooner.

  • This web site is really a walk-by for the entire data you wished about this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse right here, and also you’ll positively discover it.

  • Hi there, just became aware of your blog through Google, and found that it’s really informative. I am going to watch out for brussels. I’ll appreciate if you continue this in future. A lot of people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!

  • Thank you for another informative site. Where else could I get that kind of information written in such a perfect way? I’ve a project that I’m just now working on, and I have been on the look out for such info.

  • Greetings! I know this is somewhat off topic but I was wondering which blog platform are you using for this site? I’m getting tired of WordPress because I’ve had issues with hackers and I’m looking at alternatives for another platform. I would be fantastic if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.

  • I not to mention my friends were taking note of the best advice located on your website and unexpectedly got a terrible feeling I had not thanked the blog owner for them. Most of the women were definitely for that reason very interested to read through them and already have extremely been using those things. I appreciate you for being so kind and for having this kind of good subject matter most people are really desirous to discover. My very own sincere apologies for not saying thanks to sooner.

  • You actually make it appear so easy together with your presentation however I in finding this matter to be actually something that I think I’d by no means understand. It kind of feels too complicated and extremely vast for me. I am looking forward for your next post, I’ll try to get the dangle of it!

  • Nice read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on that. And he just bought me lunch since I found it for him smile Therefore let me rephrase that: Thank you for lunch! “We know what happens to people who stay in the middle of the road. They get run over.” by Ambrose Gwinett Bierce.

  • I think this is one of the most significant information for me. And i am glad reading your article. But want to remark on some general things, The web site style is great, the articles is really nice : D. Good job, cheers

  • Hiya, I’m really glad I’ve found this info. Today bloggers publish only about gossips and internet and this is really irritating. A good blog with interesting content, that is what I need. Thanks for keeping this website, I will be visiting it. Do you do newsletters? Can’t find it.

  • Attractive component to content. I simply stumbled upon your site and in accession capital to claim that I get actually loved account your blog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing in your feeds or even I achievement you get right of entry to persistently fast.

  • Fantastic beat ! I would like to apprentice while you amend your web site, how can i subscribe for a blog web site? The account helped me a acceptable deal. I had been tiny bit acquainted of this your broadcast offered bright clear idea

  • Generally I don’t learn post on blogs, however I would like to say that this write-up very pressured me to take a look at and do so! Your writing style has been amazed me. Thank you, quite great article.

  • I cherished as much as you will receive performed proper here. The cartoon is attractive, your authored subject matter stylish. nevertheless, you command get bought an edginess over that you want be delivering the following. ill for sure come further before once more as exactly the same just about a lot regularly within case you defend this hike.

  • Thanks a lot for the helpful article. It is also my belief that mesothelioma cancer has an incredibly long latency period of time, which means that symptoms of the disease won’t emerge until 30 to 50 years after the preliminary exposure to asbestos. Pleural mesothelioma, that’s the most common kind and is affecting the area about the lungs, might result in shortness of breath, chest muscles pains, including a persistent coughing, which may produce coughing up our blood.

  • Hello! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good results. If you know of any please share. Kudos!

  • Thanks for sharing all these wonderful articles. In addition, the perfect travel in addition to medical insurance strategy can often eradicate those problems that come with traveling abroad. The medical emergency can rapidly become costly and that’s sure to quickly place a financial burden on the family finances. Setting up in place the great travel insurance package deal prior to leaving is well worth the time and effort. Thanks a lot

  • of course like your website but you need to test the spelling on several of your posts. A number of them are rife with spelling problems and I find it very troublesome to inform the truth on the other hand I will definitely come again again.

  • hello!,I like your writing very much! share we communicate more about your article on AOL? I need an expert on this area to solve my problem. May be that’s you! Looking forward to see you.

  • A powerful share, I simply given this onto a colleague who was doing a bit of evaluation on this. And he in fact purchased me breakfast as a result of I found it for him.. smile. So let me reword that: Thnx for the deal with! But yeah Thnkx for spending the time to debate this, I feel strongly about it and love studying more on this topic. If doable, as you turn out to be expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more details? It is highly useful for me. Massive thumb up for this weblog put up!

  • My spouse and i were so excited when Emmanuel could finish up his investigation from the ideas he acquired out of the weblog. It’s not at all simplistic to simply always be handing out secrets which usually other folks may have been selling. And we also take into account we need the blog owner to thank for that. The specific illustrations you’ve made, the straightforward website menu, the friendships your site help foster – it’s got mostly exceptional, and it’s really facilitating our son in addition to us feel that this subject matter is amusing, which is certainly pretty mandatory. Many thanks for all the pieces!

  • Thanks for your fascinating article. One other problem is that mesothelioma is generally caused by the breathing of material from asbestos, which is a carcinogenic material. It is commonly witnessed among workers in the structure industry who definitely have long exposure to asbestos. It could be caused by moving into asbestos covered buildings for an extended time of time, Genetic makeup plays a crucial role, and some folks are more vulnerable for the risk compared to others.

  • Have you ever thought about writing an ebook or guest authoring on other sites? I have a blog based on the same ideas you discuss and would love to have you share some stories/information. I know my audience would enjoy your work. If you are even remotely interested, feel free to shoot me an e-mail.

  • Hey There. I found your blog using msn. This is a very well written article. I’ll make sure to bookmark it and come back to read more of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I’ll certainly comeback.

  • Greetings from Carolina! I’m bored to death at work so I decided to browse your site on my iphone during lunch break. I really like the info you provide here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home. I’m amazed at how fast your blog loaded on my phone .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyhow, awesome blog!

  • Thanks for making me to gain new ideas about computers. I also have the belief that one of the best ways to maintain your mobile computer in best condition is with a hard plastic case, and also shell, that suits over the top of the computer. These types of protective gear are model precise since they are made to fit perfectly in the natural covering. You can buy them directly from the vendor, or through third party places if they are designed for your notebook computer, however not every laptop will have a cover on the market. All over again, thanks for your ideas.

  • One more thing to say is that an online business administration training is designed for learners to be able to well proceed to bachelor’s degree courses. The Ninety credit diploma meets the lower bachelor college degree requirements and when you earn your current associate of arts in BA online, you may have access to the latest technologies with this field. Several reasons why students need to get their associate degree in business is because they may be interested in this area and want to have the general instruction necessary ahead of jumping into a bachelor education program. Many thanks for the tips you actually provide within your blog.

  • I think other web-site proprietors should take this website as an model, very clean and great user genial style and design, let alone the content. You’re an expert in this topic!

  • hi!,I really like your writing so so much! proportion we keep in touch more approximately your article on AOL? I need a specialist in this house to resolve my problem. Maybe that’s you! Taking a look forward to peer you.

  • I figured out more new stuff on this fat loss issue. One particular issue is that good nutrition is tremendously vital whenever dieting. A big reduction in bad foods, sugary meals, fried foods, sugary foods, beef, and white flour products can be necessary. Having wastes bloodsuckers, and harmful toxins may prevent ambitions for fat loss. While specific drugs briefly solve the matter, the unpleasant side effects are certainly not worth it, and they never offer more than a non permanent solution. It is a known undeniable fact that 95 of dietary fads fail. Thank you for sharing your opinions on this blog.

  • Attractive section of content. I just stumbled upon your site and in accession capital to assert that I acquire actually enjoyed account your blog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing to your augment and even I achievement you access consistently fast.

  • I do accept as true with all the concepts you have offered in your post. They are very convincing and will definitely work. Nonetheless, the posts are very short for beginners. May just you please extend them a bit from next time? Thanks for the post.

  • My brother recommended I may like this web site. He used to be entirely right. This post truly made my day. You can not believe simply how much time I had spent for this info! Thank you!

  • Greetings! I’ve been reading your blog for a long time now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Lubbock Tx! Just wanted to mention keep up the great job!

  • You actually make it appear so easy together with your presentation but I in finding this matter to be actually one thing which I feel I would by no means understand. It kind of feels too complicated and very extensive for me. I’m having a look forward for your subsequent post, I’ll attempt to get the grasp of it!

  • Good day! This is kind of off topic but I need some advice from an established blog. Is it difficult to set up your own blog? I’m not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty quick. I’m thinking about creating my own but I’m not sure where to start. Do you have any tips or suggestions? Appreciate it

  • Hey! Quick question that’s entirely off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My site looks weird when browsing from my iphone4. I’m trying to find a template or plugin that might be able to correct this issue. If you have any suggestions, please share. With thanks!

  • Wow that was odd. I just wrote an extremely long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t appear. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that over again. Anyhow, just wanted to say excellent blog!

Comments are closed.

Contact

If you would like further information or require assistance, please get in touch.

ERIK
MAGRAKEN

Personal Injury Lawyer

When not writing the BC Injury Law Blog, Erik is the managing partner at MacIsaac & Company, based in Victoria, B.C. He is also involved with combative sports regulatory issues and authors the Combat Sports Law Blog.

“Work hard, be kind and enjoy the ride!”
Erik’s Philosophy

Disclaimer