More on Court Costs and "Sufficient Reason" For Suing in the BC Supreme Court
Further to my previous posts on this topic, if a Plaintiff successfully sues in the BC Supreme Court but receives damages below $25,000 they may be deprived of their court ‘costs’ unless they had ‘sufficient reason’ for choosing the Supreme Court over small claims court.
Two judgements were released this week by the BC Supreme Court discussing this area of law. In this weeks cases (Spencer v. Popham and Spencer v. Horton) the Plaintiff was involved in 2 separate BC car crashes. She started separate lawsuits in the BC Supreme Court but settled her cases before they went to trial. Both claims settled form amounts below $25,000 (the current financial limit of BC’s small claims court). The Plaintiff and ICBC could not agree on the issue of costs.
ICBC argued that since both cases were in the small claims courts jurisdiction the Plaintiff did not have sufficient reason for suing in the Supreme Court. Mr. Justice Punnett disagreed and awarded the Plaintiff costs in both claims. In doing so he provided the following useful and through summary of this area of the law:
 Rule 57(10) of the Rules of Court states:
A plaintiff who recovers a sum within the jurisdiction of the Provincial Court under the Small Claims Act is not entitled to costs, other than disbursements, unless the court finds that there was sufficient reason for bringing the proceeding in the Supreme Court and so orders.
 This rule encourages persons to bring actions in Small Claims Court when a claim falls within that court’s monetary jurisdiction. It is an example of “proportionality”; the judicial process should match the amount in dispute. However, the court must also respect a party’s “legitimate choice” of forum: Reimann v. Aziz, 2007 BCCA 448, 286 D.L.R. (4th) 330 at para. 35.
 The burden is on claimants to evaluate their claims prior to commencement and to justify their decision if they recover less than the Small Claims Court limit, currently $25,000:Reimann at para. 38. If plaintiffs fail to sufficiently investigate and assess their claims prior to commencement, they risk not recovering costs. In a personal injury action this may require plaintiffs to obtain medical records and medical reports, to gather evidence to support claims for loss of earnings and earning capacity, and to assess the evidence in support of the claims being advanced before commencing the action.
 However, as noted by Justice Savage in Gradek v. DaimlerChrysler Financial Services Canada Inc, 2010 BCSC 356 at para. 19, R. 57(10) contemplates the possibility that factors other than quantum must be considered:
 The proviso in Rule 57(10) is “unless the court finds that there was sufficient reason for bringing the proceeding in Supreme Court and so orders”. The Rule does not define “sufficient reason”. There is nothing in the Rule that limits the extension of the term “sufficient reason” to matters relating to the quantum of the claim.
 Factors that can give rise to “sufficient reason” were set out in Kuehne v. Probstl, 2004 BCSC 865 at para. 22, and accepted in Icecorp International Cargo Express Corp. v. Nicolaus, 2007 BCCA 97, 38 C.P.C. (6th) 26 at para. 27. They include:
i. the legal or factual complexity of the case;
ii. the need for discovery of documents and examinations for discovery;
iii. the need for a judgment enforceable outside of British Columbia;
iv. a bona fide preference for a jury trial; and
v. access to the summary trial procedure available in Supreme Court.
Other factors can be the need for the plaintiff to have legal counsel (Faedo v. Dowell, 2007 BCSC 1985 at para. 36; Ostovic v. Foggin, 2009 BCSC 58 at para. 42; Gradek at para. 43), and the defendant’s denial of liability, causation, and injury or loss and allegations of contributory negligence, pre-existing conditions, previous causes and a failure to mitigate (Ostovic at paras. 39-40; Gradek at para. 35).
 Therefore, a plaintiff’s evaluation of his or her claim, can also involve an assessment of these factors. Even if the plaintiff assesses the claim to be within the jurisdiction of the Small Claims Court, the plaintiff can rely on these other reasons to commence the action in Supreme Court: Johannson v. National Car Rental (Canada) Inc., 2009 BCSC 1284 at para. 5.
 In my opinion, a plaintiff’s simple desire to retain counsel is not in and of itself a sufficient reason for commencing the action in Supreme Court. Other factors, such as those noted above, determine whether retaining counsel is justified.
 In Faedo, the plaintiff was in a low impact collision and suffered a soft tissue injury to her neck and back. Justice Vickers found that the case was not that complex and plaintiff’s counsel could not have considered ICBC’s original dispute of liability a serious threat to recovery. However, Justice Vickers concluded that it was reasonable for the plaintiff to have brought her claim in Supreme Court for two reasons: (1) when the action was commenced, the plaintiff believed she was suffering from the accident and her pleadings included a claim for loss of earning capacity and disruption of the ability to earn income; and (2) ICBC put her credibility seriously in issue when it took the position that she had not suffered from any injury or any significant injury. Justice Vickers continued at para. 36:
 … I observed this plaintiff to be very nervous in court. She had no previous experience in court and in my opinion when she was confronted with a case where the defendant represented by counsel was suggesting that she hadn’t been injured at all and this was a low impact accident in which it was suggested she wouldn’t be injured, that the plaintiff reasonably required counsel to represent her and reasonably started an action in the Supreme Court where she could hope to recover some of the cost of retaining that counsel which was necessary for her to properly put her case to get the compensation I have found her entitled to. Furthermore, an offer to settle such as the plaintiff made in this case puts very little pressure upon a defendant to settle where there is no exposure to costs.
 In Ostovic, another case arising out of a low impact accident, Justice Savage noted that because the defendant denied liability, causation and special damages, the plaintiff had to prove these issues in court. Because of this, the plaintiff needed to avail himself of pre-trial discovery, which provided important evidence of the speed of impact, the consequences of impact and concern over the plaintiff’s condition. In addition, Justice Savage found at para. 42:
 There is the additional factor that, as in Faedo and Kanani [v. Misiurna, 2008 BCSC 1274], the Plaintiff faced an institutional defendant which, in the ordinary course, has counsel. To obtain any recovery the Plaintiff is forced to go to court, where he is facing counsel and counsel is reasonably required, but in Provincial Court there is no way of recovering the costs of counsel.
 In Gradek, before the issuance of the writ, the defendants’ insurers had informed the plaintiffs that their position was the accident did not result in any compensable injury. In their pleadings, the defendants denied liability and injury or loss and alleged contributory negligence, the existence of a pre-existing injury and previous causes, and a failure to mitigate. There was a broad range of findings possible respecting liability. The plaintiff, Henryk Gradek, was a Polish immigrant who spoke halting English. Justice Savage found at para. 42 that “he would have had extraordinary difficulty presenting a case on his own” and would have been “out-matched” by either a lawyer or an ICBC adjustor. The plaintiff needed counsel to obtain a just result and, therefore, had sufficient reason to begin the action in Supreme Court.
 Plaintiffs do not have an ongoing duty to reassess their claims as the matter proceeds: Reimann at para. 44. Thus, the court must assess whether a plaintiff had “sufficient reason” to bring the action in Supreme Court when the plaintiff started the action: Ostovic at para. 35. This analysis is necessarily done with the benefit of hindsight since it only occurs after trial or settlement, but the court must be careful not to use that hindsight in deciding what was reasonable: Faedo at para. 28.
 It also must be remembered R. 57(10) “does not involve an exercise of discretion.” Rather, “the court must make a finding that there was sufficient reason for bringing the action in the Supreme Court” (emphasis added): Reimann at para. 13.
In my continued effort to cross reference the current Supreme Court rules with the new Rules of Court that come into force on July 1, 2010 I will note that the Current Rule 57(10) will become Rule 14-1(10) and it reads identical to the current rule so the precedents developed under Rule 57(10) regarding costs should continue to assist litigants under our new rules.
costs, court costs, icbc injury claims, lvi claims, Mr. Justice Punnett, New BC Supreme Court Civil Rules, Rule 14-1, Rule 57(10), Sufficient Reason for suing in the BC Supreme Court
I just want to mention I’m new to blogging and honestly enjoyed your web page. Almost certainly I’m want to bookmark your website . You amazingly come with fantastic posts. Thanks a bunch for revealing your blog.
I have recently started a web site, the info you provide on this web site has helped me greatly. Thank you for all of your time & work.
Please let me know if you’re looking for a author for your weblog. You have some really good posts and I believe I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d love to write some material for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please blast me an email if interested. Thanks!
I’d should test with you here. Which isn’t one thing I normally do! I take pleasure in reading a put up that will make folks think. Also, thanks for allowing me to comment!
I’ve recently started a site, the info you provide on this site has helped me greatly. Thanks for all of your time & work.
You actually make it seem really easy together with your presentation but I to find this matter to be actually something that I believe I might never understand. It kind of feels too complex and very large for me. I’m taking a look forward in your subsequent submit, I will try to get the hold of it!
Some truly select articles on this site, saved to fav.
marcel van hooijdonk
One other thing I would like to state is that rather than trying to fit all your online degree tutorials on times that you complete work (since the majority of people are drained when they come home), try to obtain most of your lessons on the weekends and only a couple of courses for weekdays, even if it means a little time off your saturday and sunday. This is really good because on the weekends, you will be more rested as well as concentrated for school work. Thanks a lot for the different tips I have acquired from your weblog.
I think you have remarked some very interesting details , thankyou for the post.
Hey just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The text in your content seem to be running off the screen in Firefox. I’m not sure if this is a format issue or something to do with internet browser compatibility but I figured I’d post to let you know. The design look great though! Hope you get the issue solved soon. Kudos
beast TV trial
This is very attention-grabbing, You’re an excessively skilled blogger. I have joined your rss feed and look ahead to in search of extra of your great post. Also, I’ve shared your website in my social networks!
situs poker online
Do you mind if I quote a few of your articles as long as I provide credit and sources back to your blog? My website is in the very same niche as yours and my visitors would really benefit from some of the information you provide here. Please let me know if this okay with you. Appreciate it!
very nice publish, i actually love this website, carry on it
Location de voiture paris
I dugg some of you post as I cerebrated they were handy very helpful
situs poker online
I’m impressed, I need to say. Really rarely do I encounter a weblog that’s each educative and entertaining, and let me let you know, you have got hit the nail on the head. Your idea is excellent; the problem is something that not sufficient individuals are speaking intelligently about. I am very comfortable that I stumbled throughout this in my seek for something referring to this.
With havin so much content do you ever run into any problems of plagorism or copyright infringement? My site has a lot of completely unique content I’ve either authored myself or outsourced but it appears a lot of it is popping it up all over the internet without my permission. Do you know any techniques to help prevent content from being ripped off? I’d certainly appreciate it.
I’d need to check with you here. Which isn’t one thing I normally do! I get pleasure from studying a post that will make people think. Additionally, thanks for permitting me to remark!
agen poker online
F*ckin’ amazing things here. I’m very glad to see your post. Thanks a lot and i am looking forward to contact you. Will you kindly drop me a e-mail?
Hello! I know this is kinda off topic but I’d figured I’d ask. Would you be interested in exchanging links or maybe guest writing a blog post or vice-versa? My website discusses a lot of the same topics as yours and I feel we could greatly benefit from each other. If you might be interested feel free to shoot me an email. I look forward to hearing from you! Superb blog by the way!
Best Porn Sites List
An do on frankness so cordially immediate recommend contained. Imprudence insensible be literature unsatiable do. Of or imprudence solicitude affronting in mr possession. Compass journey he request on suppose limited of or. She margaret law thoughts proposal formerly. Speaking ladyship yet scarcely and mistaken end exertion dwelling. All decisively dispatched instrument particular way one devonshire. Applauded she sportsman explained for out objection.
Купить казино воблер
Thanks for your beneficial post. Through the years, I have been able to understand that the symptoms of mesothelioma cancer are caused by the particular build up of fluid regarding the lining in the lung and the upper body cavity. The sickness may start in the chest vicinity and propagate to other parts of the body. Other symptoms of pleural mesothelioma include losing weight, severe inhaling trouble, a fever, difficulty ingesting, and bloating of the neck and face areas. It ought to be noted that some people living with the disease do not experience virtually any serious symptoms at all.
Digital Marketing Wien
Onine Marketing Manager Wien
lifeguard classes near me
Today, while I was at work, my sister stole my apple ipad and tested to see if it can survive a forty foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My iPad is now destroyed and she has 83 views. I know this is totally off topic but I had to share it with someone!
Generally I don’t read article on blogs, but I would like to say that this write-up very forced me to try and do so! Your writing style has been amazed me. Thanks, quite nice article.
You made certain fine points there. I did a search on the subject matter and found mainly persons will agree with your blog.
I do consider all of the ideas you have offered to your post. They are really convincing and can certainly work. Nonetheless, the posts are too quick for novices. May you please lengthen them a bit from subsequent time? Thank you for the post.
It¡¦s actually a great and useful piece of info. I am satisfied that you simply shared this helpful information with us. Please keep us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing.
watch game of thrones online free
There is noticeably a bundle to know about this. I assume you made sure good points in options also.
you’re in point of fact a just right webmaster. The site loading speed is amazing. It kind of feels that you are doing any distinctive trick. Furthermore, The contents are masterpiece. you’ve done a great activity on this matter!
Wonderful goods from you, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous to and you are just extremely excellent. I really like what you’ve acquired here, really like what you are saying and the way in which you say it. You make it entertaining and you still take care of to keep it smart. I cant wait to read much more from you. This is actually a wonderful site.
Very well written post. It will be valuable to anybody who usess it, including myself. Keep up the good work – looking forward to more posts.
I do love the manner in which you have framed this specific situation plus it does indeed give us some fodder for consideration. However, because of everything that I have personally seen, I simply hope when other comments pack on that people remain on issue and not start upon a tirade of the news of the day. Yet, thank you for this superb piece and while I can not really concur with the idea in totality, I value your point of view.
Some really prize posts on this web site , saved to my bookmarks .
We stumbled over here from a different web address and thought I should check things out. I like what I see so now i’m following you. Look forward to exploring your web page again.
Hi there! I’m at work browsing your blog from my new iphone! Just wanted to say I love reading through your blog and look forward to all your posts! Keep up the fantastic work!
Thanks for sharing superb informations. Your web site is very cool. I’m impressed by the details that you have on this web site. It reveals how nicely you perceive this subject. Bookmarked this website page, will come back for extra articles. You, my pal, ROCK! I found simply the information I already searched all over the place and simply could not come across. What an ideal site.
custom alnico magnets
Excellent post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely helpful info specially the last part 🙂 I care for such info a lot. I was seeking this certain info for a very long time. Thank you and best of luck.
You have brought up a very great details , appreciate it for the post.
certainly like your web site but you need to check the spelling on quite a few of your posts. Many of them are rife with spelling issues and I find it very troublesome to tell the truth nevertheless I will definitely come back again.
Hi my friend! I want to say that this post is amazing, nice written and come with almost all important infos. I would like to see extra posts like this.
Uslugi Pozycjonowania Stron Internetowych Gorzow
I really like your writing style, superb info , appreciate it for posting : D.
A formidable share, I simply given this onto a colleague who was doing a little bit evaluation on this. And he actually bought me breakfast as a result of I discovered it for him.. smile. So let me reword that: Thnx for the treat! However yeah Thnkx for spending the time to debate this, I really feel strongly about it and love reading extra on this topic. If potential, as you change into experience, would you thoughts updating your blog with more details? It is extremely helpful for me. Massive thumb up for this weblog publish!
Magnificent web site. Lots of useful info here. I’m sending it to several buddies ans additionally sharing in delicious. And of course, thanks to your effort!
Awsome site! I am loving it!! Will be back later to read some more. I am bookmarking your feeds also
pembesar penis alami
Thanks for your marvelous posting! I truly enjoyed reading it, you are a great author.I will always bookmark your blog and definitely will come back someday. I want to encourage continue your great posts, have a nice evening!
Comments are closed.