More on Rule 66, Rule 37B, ICBC Claims and Costs
Reasons for judgment were released today by the BC Supreme Court dealing with 2 issues of interest to me, Costs consequences under Rule 66 and Rule 37B.
In today’s case (Schnare v. Roberts) the Plaintiff was injured in a motor vehicle collision. The Plaintiff sued for damages under Rule 66. The Plaintiff made a formal offer of settlement and ICBC did not accept it. The Plaintiff proceeded to trial and the verdict more than doubled the Plaintiff’s settlement offer. (click here to read my previous post regarding the trial judgment).
Today’s judgment dealt with the costs consequences. ICBC argued that the Plaintiff should be limited to costs under Rule 66 (which are capped at an amount less than regular Tariff costs under the BC Supreme Court Rules) because the lawsuit was brought initially under Rule 66. Madam Justice Adair disagreed with ICBC’s submission and noted that since the trial went beyond the Rule 66 2 day limit that constituted ‘special circumstances’ which permitted the court to order costs outside of the Rule 66 costs. Madam Justice Adair reasoned as follows:
 Sub-rules (29) and (29.1) of Rule 66 provide (italics added):
(29) Unless the court orders otherwise or the parties consent, and subject to Rule 57 (10), the amount of costs, exclusive of disbursements, to which a party is entitled is as follows:
(a) if the time spent on the hearing of the trial is one day or less, $5 000;
(b) if the time spent on the hearing of the trial is more than one day, $6 600.
(29.1) In exercising its discretion under subrule (29), the court may consider a settlement offer delivered in accordance with Rule 37 or 37A whether or not other special circumstances exist.
Rules 37 and 37A have been repealed and replaced with Rule 37B.
 In my view, Ms. Schnare’s case was not the type of case contemplated by Rule 66. By October 2008, the parties themselves realized that two days would not be sufficient for trial. Even a more generous estimate of three days turned out to be insufficient to deal with the evidence on the relevant issues in the case and with submissions (including submissions on the admissibility of documentary evidence). Although court adjourned somewhat early in the afternoon on January 28, 2009, it sat late on January 29, 2009, to ensure that a witness’ evidence could be completed. I did not consider counsel were inefficient in their use of time. I am satisfied that the length of the trial itself constitutes “special circumstances” in this case. See Kailey v. Kellner, 2008 BCSC 224, 56 C.P.C. (6th) 40, where, in comparable circumstances, Mr. Justice Parrett also found the length the trial constituted “special circumstances” justifying a departure from the fixed costs under Rule 66(29), and awarded costs on Scale B.
 In my opinion, the appropriate order respecting costs (before considering matters under Rule 37B) was and is that the plaintiff should recover her costs on Scale B of Appendix B.
The second issue worth noting were the costs consequences under Rule 37B. The Plaintiff argued that they should be awarded double costs from the date of their formal settlement offer onward. Madam Justice agreed and engaged in the below analysis and in doing so made some critical comments about an expert physician (Dr. McPherson) who ‘was very closely tied to ICBC…for over a decade‘ in the defence of personal injury claims:
19] Should the plaintiff’s January 26, 2009 offer have been accepted, and the costs of the trial avoided? Analysis of this question is not to be based on hindsight once the final result is known, as noted in Bailey v. Jang, 2008 BCSC 1372, 63 C.P.C. (6th) 291, at para. 24. Nevertheless, in my view, the defendants should have given that offer much more serious consideration when looking at the risks of going to trial.
 The defendants’ defence to Ms. Schnare’s claims for substantial damages rested primarily on the shoulders of their expert, Dr. McPherson, the only defence witness. However, there were serious risks in that strategy. Dr. McPherson was very closely tied to ICBC, and had been for over a decade. This was not a secret, and had been the subject of media reports, which were used to cross-examine Dr. McPherson. As counsel for the defendants must have appreciated, these ties made an issue of Dr. McPherson’s impartiality and credibility, and impaired his value as a expert. Dr. McPherson’s evidence, unlike that of Dr. Van Rijn and Mr. McLean, did nothing to explain Ms. Schnare’s continuing symptoms and physical difficulties, and provided little assistance to the court. His rejection of the possibility that there could be movement of Ms. Schnare’s sacroiliac joints led inevitably to his conclusion that her complaints could not be accident-related, and to speculate that Ms. Schnare possibly had a condition that Dr. McPherson conceded was extremely rare. As I noted in my reasons, Dr. McPherson was unhelpfully dismissive of opinions other than his own. In my view, the defendants’ reliance on Dr. McPherson’s opinions to defend against Ms. Schnare’s claims was unreasonable in face of the plaintiff’s eve-of-trial offer to settle. The offer represented a very substantial discount from the amounts Ms. Schnare sought at trial. A more reasonable assessment of the potential risk that Dr. McPherson’s opinions would be unpersuasive (as I found them) should have led the defendants to accept Ms. Schnare’s last offer, in which case the costs of the trial would have been avoided. This factor supports the plaintiff.
 The final damages awarded to Ms. Schnare were more than twice the amount of Ms. Schnare’s offer. This factor also supports the plaintiff.
 With respect to the relative financial circumstances of the parties, I consider this factor neutral.
 Taking into account the underlying legislative policy behind Rule 37B, that Ms. Schnare’s offer represented a very substantial discount off her damage claims presented at trial and if accepted would have avoided the costs of the trial, and that the amount awarded was significantly more than the amount of Ms. Schnare’s offer, in my view it is appropriate to award the plaintiff double costs for steps taken after January 26, 2009.
costs, Dr. McPherson, icbc information, icbc injury claims, ICBC settlement, Rule 37B, rule 66, Schnare v. Roberts
her latest blog
I just want to say I’m beginner to blogging and truly liked this web page. Very likely I’m likely to bookmark your website . You amazingly have amazing stories. Cheers for sharing your blog.
Howdy are using WordPress for your blog platform? I’m new to the blog world but I’m trying to get started and set up my own. Do you require any html coding expertise to make your own blog? Any help would be really appreciated!
Wow, marvelous weblog structure! How long have you been running a blog for? you make running a blog glance easy. The total look of your web site is excellent, as well as the content material!
fotograf slubny Oswiecim
My wife and i ended up being ecstatic that Edward managed to finish up his homework via the ideas he grabbed using your weblog. It’s not at all simplistic to simply always be giving for free tricks some people could have been selling. And we all keep in mind we’ve got the writer to appreciate for this. The entire explanations you’ve made, the simple website navigation, the friendships you make it possible to instill – it’s all overwhelming, and it’s really letting our son in addition to us feel that the article is satisfying, which is particularly essential. Thanks for everything!
Hey! This post couldn’t be written any better! Reading through this post reminds me of my old room mate! He always kept chatting about this. I will forward this post to him. Fairly certain he will have a good read. Thanks for sharing!
I am really inspired along with your writing abilities as smartly as with the format on your blog. Is that this a paid subject or did you modify it yourself? Either way stay up the excellent quality writing, it’s rare to see a great blog like this one today..
marcel van hooijdonk
Good – I should certainly pronounce, impressed with your web site. I had no trouble navigating through all tabs and related information ended up being truly easy to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it at all. Quite unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or anything, site theme . a tones way for your customer to communicate. Excellent task.
Underground Elephant Jason Kulpa
Hello my friend! I want to say that this post is awesome, nice written and include almost all significant infos. I would like to see extra posts like this.
Hi, Neat post. There’s a problem together with your site in web explorer, could test this… IE nonetheless is the market leader and a large element of people will miss your magnificent writing because of this problem.
situs poker online
Oh my goodness! an amazing article dude. Thanks However I am experiencing challenge with ur rss . Don’t know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anyone getting identical rss problem? Anyone who is aware of kindly respond. Thnkx
It is appropriate time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you some interesting things or tips. Maybe you could write next articles referring to this article. I wish to read even more things about it!
I used to be more than happy to find this internet-site.I wanted to thanks to your time for this wonderful read!! I definitely having fun with each little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you weblog post.
You could definitely see your skills within the work you write. The world hopes for more passionate writers such as you who are not afraid to mention how they believe. All the time follow your heart. “If you feel yourself falling, let go and glide.” by Steffen Francisco.
Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. After all I will be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again very soon!
Merely wanna admit that this is extremely helpful, Thanks for taking your time to write this.
Orbit 110 bearking
I’m impressed, I have to say. Really rarely do I encounter a blog that’s both educative and entertaining, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail on the head. Your thought is excellent; the problem is something that not sufficient individuals are speaking intelligently about. I’m very glad that I stumbled throughout this in my search for something relating to this.
Social Media Marketing Wien
Digital Marketing Wien
затворы sung do
Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I’ve really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again very soon!
I’ve recently started a website, the info you offer on this site has helped me greatly. Thanks for all of your time & work. “A physicist is an atom’s way of knowing about atoms.” by George Wald.
You completed some good points there. I did a search on the issue and found mainly folks will consent with your blog.
Wonderful goods from you, man. I’ve take into account your stuff prior to and you’re simply too fantastic. I really like what you’ve acquired right here, certainly like what you’re stating and the best way wherein you are saying it. You are making it entertaining and you continue to take care of to stay it sensible. I can not wait to read far more from you. That is really a wonderful web site.
I like the efforts you have put in this, regards for all the great articles.
lifeguard training near me
I was suggested this web site by my cousin. I am not sure whether this post is written by him as no one else know such detailed about my trouble. You are amazing! Thanks!
As soon as I observed this web site I went on reddit to share some of the love with them.
Hi, i think that i saw you visited my site thus i came to “return the favor”.I am trying to find things to improve my web site!I suppose its ok to use a few of your ideas!!
where can i watch game of thrones
Hey there would you mind letting me know which webhost you’re working with? I’ve loaded your blog in 3 completely different browsers and I must say this blog loads a lot quicker then most. Can you recommend a good internet hosting provider at a fair price? Thanks a lot, I appreciate it!
I’ve learn a few good stuff here. Definitely value bookmarking for revisiting. I wonder how a lot effort you place to make one of these excellent informative web site.
Great blog! I am loving it!! Will be back later to read some more. I am taking your feeds also.
Definitely, what a fantastic website and illuminating posts, I definitely will bookmark your website.Have an awsome day!
It is in point of fact a great and useful piece of information. I am happy that you just shared this helpful info with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.
I don’t even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was good. I don’t know who you are but certainly you are going to a famous blogger if you aren’t already 😉 Cheers!
Very interesting information!Perfect just what I was looking for! “Being rich is having money being wealthy is having time.” by Margaret Bonnano.
sorry mf dj taydeville ft lil jay from crime mob
I dugg some of you post as I cerebrated they were very beneficial invaluable
One thing I’d really like to reply to is that fat burning plan fast can be achieved by the perfect diet and exercise. Your size not only affects appearance, but also the entire quality of life. Self-esteem, melancholy, health risks, and also physical skills are damaged in extra weight. It is possible to do everything right whilst still having a gain. Should this happen, a condition may be the reason. While an excessive amount of food instead of enough physical exercise are usually to blame, common health concerns and key prescriptions could greatly help to increase size. Thx for your post here.
Seo Google Gorzow
Very interesting details you have noted , thankyou for putting up. “Pleasure and love are the pinions of great deeds.” by Charles Fox.
I found your weblog site on google and verify a few of your early posts. Proceed to keep up the very good operate. I simply extra up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. In search of ahead to studying extra from you later on!…
Good write-up, I’m regular visitor of one’s web site, maintain up the nice operate, and It’s going to be a regular visitor for a lengthy time.
pembesar alat vital alami
I’m not that much of a internet reader to be honest but your sites really nice, keep it up! I’ll go ahead and bookmark your site to come back later. Many thanks
Comments are closed.