Another Rule 37B Case – Plaintiff Awarded Trial Costs Despite not Beating Defence Offer

Written by admin on . Posted in BC Supreme Court Costs Cases, Civil Procedure, Jury Trials, Uncategorized.

(Please note the case discussed in this post was overturned on Appeal, you can click here for an updated post and click hear to read the BC Court of Appeal decision)
Reasons for judgement were released today dealing with costs consequences under Rule 37B.
Although Rule 37B has some flexibility to its outcomes, normally when a Plaintiff fails to beat a defence formal settlement offer after trial the Plaintiff is deprived of his/her costs and the Defendant is awarded theirs.  Today’s case had a result which departs from this norm.
In today’s case (Gehlen v. Rana) the Plaintiff was injured when she was a passenger involved in a rear-end car crash.  The Defendant admitted fault for the crash but denied liability to the Plaintiff claiming that the Plaintiff “was not present in the vehicle at the time of the accident“.  The Defendant made a formal offer to settle the Plaintiff’s claim for $22,000 plus disbursements.  The Plaintiff rejected this offer and went to trial.  After trial the Jury awarded the Plaintiff total damages of just over $13,000.
The Plaintiff brought a motion for her costs and the Defendant brought a counter motion for their costs from the time of the offer onward.  Mr. Justice Leask held that the Plaintiff should be awarded her full costs, even for steps taken after the formal settlement offer despite not beating the offer.  His reasoning was as follows:

[18]         As to s-s. (d), I consider two other factors to be relevant.  First, the defendant’s choice of trial by jury, which considerably increases the costs.  Second, the manner in which the defence was conducted – to accuse the plaintiff and her family of fraud – that accusation having been rejected by the jury.

[19]         Turning last to s-s. (a) – the most important question – whether the offer was one that ought reasonably to have been accepted.  On this issue, I agree with Goepel J.’s judgment in A.E. v. D.W.J., 2009 BCSC 505, at paragraph 55:

[55]      … this analysis is not one to be done based on hindsight once the final result is known.  The reasonableness of the plaintiff’s decision not to accept the offer to settle must be assessed without reference to the court’s decision.

[20]         I am satisfied that the defendant’s denial of liability, and the allegations of fraud that underlay that denial, dominated the plaintiff’s thinking at the time the offer to settle was made and, indeed, throughout the entire pre-trial period.  Knowing that her claim was not fraudulent and knowing the persuasive evidence she had to rebut the allegation of fraud, the plaintiff thought she had a good answer to the defendant’s “low ball” offer to settle.  With hindsight, it is obvious that her counsel did not anticipate the defendant’s vigorous attack on her credibility including the detailed attack on her employment resumé and the emphasis on her second accident.  Her counsel’s trial preparation did not include preparing her or her witnesses for these issues.  However, analyzing the plaintiff’s decision not to accept the defendant’s offer to settle without the benefit of hindsight, I am satisfied that it was not an offer that ought reasonably to have been accepted.

[21]         Analyzing all the Rule 37B(6) factors, I am satisfied that the plaintiff is entitled to a judgment under Rule 37B(5)(c) and is entitled “in respect of all … of the steps taken in the proceeding after the date of delivery … of the offer to settle, costs to which the party would have been entitled had the offer not been made” (emphasis added).

I turn now to the plaintiff’s submission for 1.5 times Scale B costs because of the allegation of fraud made by the defendant and the manner in which those allegations were pursued at trial.  Having taken that factor into account in my analysis of Rule 37B(6), I believe it would represent a form of “double counting” to award increased costs for this factor.  My conclusion is that the plaintiff is entitled to her costs and reasonable disbursements of the entire proceeding on Scale B.

costs consequences, formal settlement offers, Gehlan v. Rana, icbc jury trials, ICBC Settlemnt Offers, Mr. Justice Leask, Rule 37B, trials and costs consequences

Comments (49)

  • 릴게임다운로드

    One more thing. I really believe that there are many travel insurance websites of reputable companies that permit you to enter holiday details and have you the quotations. You can also purchase an international travel cover policy on-line by using your own credit card. All that you should do is to enter all travel details and you can be aware of the plans side-by-side. You only need to find the plan that suits your finances and needs and then use your credit card to buy that. Travel insurance on the internet is a good way to take a look for a respected company to get international holiday insurance. Thanks for revealing your ideas.

  • W88 Thai

    Thank you for sharing excellent informations. Your website is very cool. I’m impressed by the details that you have on this site. It reveals how nicely you perceive this subject. Bookmarked this website page, will come back for extra articles. You, my pal, ROCK! I found simply the information I already searched everywhere and just couldn’t come across. What a great site.

  • fotograf slubny Andrychow

    A powerful share, I simply given this onto a colleague who was doing somewhat analysis on this. And he actually bought me breakfast as a result of I discovered it for him.. smile. So let me reword that: Thnx for the deal with! However yeah Thnkx for spending the time to debate this, I feel strongly about it and love reading more on this topic. If potential, as you grow to be experience, would you thoughts updating your blog with more details? It is extremely helpful for me. Huge thumb up for this weblog put up!

  • http://forum.aunbox.com/member.php?339421-kwmzyfpgrtr

    One more thing. In my opinion that there are lots of travel insurance web sites of reliable companies that allow you enter holiday details and acquire you the estimates. You can also purchase the actual international holiday insurance policy on internet by using your own credit card. All you have to do is to enter all your travel particulars and you can begin to see the plans side-by-side. Merely find the plan that suits your financial allowance and needs after which use your credit card to buy them. Travel insurance on the internet is a good way to start looking for a respected company pertaining to international holiday insurance. Thanks for revealing your ideas.

  • ajrxnlvhffltm

    Fantastic beat ! I would like to apprentice while you amend your website, how could i subscribe for a blog site? The account aided me a acceptable deal. I had been a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast provided bright clear concept

  • beast TV

    Hi! Someone in my Myspace group shared this site with us so I came to take a look. I’m definitely loving the information. I’m book-marking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Excellent blog and brilliant design and style.

  • situs poker online

    My partner and I absolutely love your blog and find most of your post’s to be just what I’m looking for. can you offer guest writers to write content in your case? I wouldn’t mind producing a post or elaborating on a number of the subjects you write related to here. Again, awesome website!

  • online poker

    The following time I read a weblog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as a lot as this one. I imply, I know it was my option to read, however I truly thought youd have one thing attention-grabbing to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you can repair if you werent too busy on the lookout for attention.

  • location brabus

    Hello very cool site!! Man .. Excellent .. Wonderful .. I’ll bookmark your web site and take the feeds additionally…I am satisfied to seek out numerous useful info right here in the post, we want work out extra techniques on this regard, thank you for sharing.

  • poker

    There are certainly a number of details like that to take into consideration. That may be a great point to carry up. I offer the ideas above as general inspiration however clearly there are questions like the one you deliver up the place a very powerful factor will likely be working in trustworthy good faith. I don?t know if greatest practices have emerged round issues like that, but I am sure that your job is clearly identified as a good game. Each girls and boys feel the affect of just a moment’s pleasure, for the remainder of their lives.

  • 릴게임

    Hello! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a group of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community in the same niche. Your blog provided us useful information to work on. You have done a extraordinary job!

  • situs poker online

    Today, I went to the beach front with my children. I found a sea shell and gave it to my 4 year old daughter and said “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.” She placed the shell to her ear and screamed. There was a hermit crab inside and it pinched her ear. She never wants to go back! LoL I know this is completely off topic but I had to tell someone!

  • poker online

    It’s really a cool and useful piece of info. I am glad that you simply shared this useful info with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.

  • W88

    I like this blog so much, saved to fav. “Respect for the fragility and importance of an individual life is still the mark of an educated man.” by Norman Cousins.

  • 야마토게임다운로드

    Thanks for your helpful post. Over time, I have come to understand that the particular symptoms of mesothelioma are caused by the build up associated fluid between lining of the lung and the upper body cavity. The illness may start while in the chest area and multiply to other limbs. Other symptoms of pleural mesothelioma cancer include fat loss, severe deep breathing trouble, nausea, difficulty swallowing, and bloating of the neck and face areas. It should be noted that some people having the disease will not experience almost any serious symptoms at all.

  • затворы sung do

    What i do not realize is if truth be told how you are not actually a lot more neatly-liked than you might be now. You are very intelligent. You recognize therefore significantly on the subject of this matter, made me in my opinion believe it from numerous various angles. Its like women and men aren’t fascinated until it is one thing to accomplish with Woman gaga! Your personal stuffs excellent. Always maintain it up!

  • 토토사이트

    Hello my friend! I want to say that this post is awesome, nice written and come with approximately all important infos. I’d like to peer more posts like this.

  • 우리카지노

    Thanks for your publication. I also think that laptop computers are getting to be more and more popular today, and now are sometimes the only kind of computer utilized in a household. It is because at the same time actually becoming more and more inexpensive, their working power is growing to the point where they can be as highly effective as desktop from just a few in years past.

  • 토토사이트

    Hi! I could have sworn I’ve been to this blog before but after browsing through some of the post I realized it’s new to me. Nonetheless, I’m definitely delighted I found it and I’ll be bookmarking and checking back often!

  • Opiekunka Praca Niemcy

    Wow! This can be one particular of the most useful blogs We’ve ever arrive across on this subject. Basically Excellent. I am also a specialist in this topic therefore I can understand your hard work.

  • 먹튀검증단

    As I website possessor I believe the content material here is rattling excellent , appreciate it for your hard work. You should keep it up forever! Best of luck.

  • 메이저사이트

    Hey there, I think your website might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your website in Ie, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, fantastic blog!

  • lk21

    fantastic post, very informative. I wonder why the other experts of this sector don’t notice this. You must continue your writing. I’m sure, you’ve a huge readers’ base already!

  • obat kuat alami

    What’s Happening i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I’ve found It positively helpful and it has helped me out loads. I hope to contribute & help other users like its helped me. Great job.

  • 메이저사이트

    Thanks for some other fantastic post. The place else may anyone get that type of info in such a perfect way of writing? I’ve a presentation subsequent week, and I’m at the search for such info.

Comments are closed.

Contact

If you would like further information or require assistance, please get in touch.

ERIK
MAGRAKEN

Personal Injury Lawyer

When not writing the BC Injury Law Blog, Erik is the managing partner at MacIsaac & Company, based in Victoria, B.C. He is also involved with combative sports regulatory issues and authors the Combat Sports Law Blog.

“Work hard, be kind and enjoy the ride!”
Erik’s Philosophy

Disclaimer