Is Comparing an Expert Witness to a "Wizard Buffoon" Fair Game in an Injury Trial?
Reasons for judgement were recently shared with me addressing the scope of permissible closing arguments criticizing an opposing expert witness in an injury claim before a jury. In short the Court held that comparing an opposing expert to Johnny Carson’s Carnac The Magnificent crossed the line.
In the recent case (Walker v. ICBC) the Plaintiff sued for damages for serious injuries sustained in a motor vehicle incident. In defending the case ICBC called a professional engineer who provided evidence which contradicted the Plaintiff’s expert. The expert was vigorously cross examined. In closing arguments to the Jury the expert was compared to Carnac the Magnificent. In finding this comment beyond the permissible scope Mr. Justice Voith provided the following reasons:
 The Submission addressed Dr. Toor and his evidence at paras. 78-87 and elsewhere. The attack made on Dr. Toor had at least two components or aspects, each of which was repeated in different ways and each of which was inappropriate. The first was that Dr. Toor, a professional person, was knowingly and intentionally made an object of derision and ridicule. Counsel for the Plaintiff accepted this and did not resile from it. If Dr. Toor’s evidence was ridiculous, he argued, Dr. Toor deserved to be ridiculed…
 The second statement, “although Johnny Carson is dead, the Amazing Karnak lives on”, is inappropriate. The defendant in argument described the Karnac figure as a “wizard buffoon”. Counsel for the Plaintiff agreed. He went on to accept that the Karnac figure was a “ridiculous, turbanned and bejewelled caricature”.
 Earlier during the trial, counsel for the plaintiff had held up a sealed envelope in his hand and began to ask Dr. Toor what was in it. I prevented counsel from proceeding. I did not appreciate at the time, however, that this bit of theatre was intended to presage things to come and to lay the groundwork for counsel’s subsequent submissions. I accept that counsel can be vigorous in its attack on the evidence and qualificaitons of an expert. That attack may well use some “drama and pathos”: Cahoon at para. 18. I do not consider or accept that it should extend to ridicule based on counsel’s belief that a witness’s evidence is ridiculous. It should not depict or describe a professional person, qualified to give expert evidence, as a fool or buffoon based on counsel’s perception of that witness. In this case, the indirect assertion that Dr. Toor was a buffoon was reinforced by the sarcastic tone, again often independently acceptable, which counsel for the plaintiff used in these submissions.
A mistrial was eventually declared. The reasons for judgement are not publicly available but, as always, I’m happy to provide a copy to anyone who contacts me and requests one.
I am advised this matter is under appeal and will post further on this topic after the BC Court of Appeal weighs in on this issue. Whatever the final judicial outcome addressing the scope of fair criticism, its a safe bet BC won’t mirror New Mexico’s satirical 1995 proposal requiring expert witnesses to dress like wizards while testifying.
bc injury law, closing arguments, Mr. Justice Voith, Walker v. Doe
click here to investigate
I simply want to mention I’m new to blogs and absolutely liked you’re website. Most likely I’m going to bookmark your blog . You absolutely have beneficial article content. Thanks a bunch for revealing your web page.
I truly enjoy examining on this web site, it contains wonderful posts. “The living is a species of the dead and not a very attractive one.” by Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche.
Simply wish to say your article is as astonishing. The clarity in your post is simply excellent and i can assume you are an expert on this subject. Fine with your permission let me to grab your RSS feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please keep up the rewarding work.
whoah this blog is wonderful i love reading your articles. Keep up the good work! You know, lots of people are searching around for this info, you could help them greatly.
Hi! Would you mind if I share your blog with my myspace group? There’s a lot of people that I think would really enjoy your content. Please let me know. Cheers
It’s really a cool and useful piece of info. I am satisfied that you just shared this useful info with us. Please stay us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing.
agen poker online
I know this if off topic but I’m looking into starting my own blog and was wondering what all is needed to get set up? I’m assuming having a blog like yours would cost a pretty penny? I’m not very internet savvy so I’m not 100 sure. Any suggestions or advice would be greatly appreciated. Thank you
whoah this blog is excellent i love reading your posts. Keep up the great work! You know, a lot of people are hunting around for this info, you could help them greatly.
Hello, Neat post. There’s an issue along with your website in internet explorer, may check this… IE nonetheless is the marketplace leader and a big element of people will pass over your wonderful writing due to this problem.
you may have an important weblog here! would you wish to make some invite posts on my weblog?
I wanted to draft you the tiny observation to finally thank you so much yet again relating to the lovely information you have shown above. It’s simply shockingly generous of you to offer freely exactly what a lot of folks would’ve offered for an ebook in making some money for their own end, most importantly seeing that you could possibly have done it in the event you decided. Those inspiring ideas additionally acted to provide a good way to be sure that many people have the identical interest just as mine to see very much more around this issue. Certainly there are some more enjoyable situations in the future for many who discover your blog post.
затворы sung do
I enjoy what you guys are up too. This kind of clever work and reporting! Keep up the superb works guys I’ve incorporated you guys to blogroll.
Excellent read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing some research on that. And he actually bought me lunch because I found it for him smile Thus let me rephrase that: Thanks for lunch!
Would you be interested in exchanging links?
lifeguard courses near me
I was curious if you ever considered changing the layout of your blog? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of text for only having 1 or 2 images. Maybe you could space it out better?
Thanks for every other informative website. Where else may I get that type of information written in such a perfect approach? I’ve a venture that I am simply now working on, and I have been on the glance out for such information.
I’m not sure where you are getting your info, but great topic. I needs to spend some time learning more or understanding more. Thanks for magnificent information I was looking for this info for my mission.
Thanks for these pointers. One thing I additionally believe is that credit cards supplying a 0 rate of interest often entice consumers with zero interest, instant acceptance and easy online balance transfers, nonetheless beware of the top factor that will certainly void the 0 easy neighborhood annual percentage rate plus throw you out into the terrible house in no time.
I was looking at some of your content on this site and I believe this internet site is real informative ! Keep on putting up.
I was looking through some of your blog posts on this website and I believe this site is very informative ! Keep posting .
I really like your writing style, fantastic information, thanks for posting : D.
Praca Opiekunka Osob Starszych W Niemczech
F*ckin’ remarkable issues here. I am very glad to look your article. Thank you so much and i am taking a look forward to touch you. Will you kindly drop me a mail?
Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. After all I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again soon!
I have been browsing online greater than three hours today, yet I never discovered any fascinating article like yours. It is pretty price sufficient for me. In my opinion, if all webmasters and bloggers made good content material as you did, the internet will likely be much more useful than ever before. “Now I see the secret of the making of the best persons.” by Walt Whitman.
I am now not sure the place you are getting your info, however great topic. I needs to spend some time studying much more or understanding more. Thank you for great information I used to be searching for this information for my mission.
SORRY MF DJ TAYDEVILLE FT LIL JAY FROM CRIME MOB
I am often to blogging and i really appreciate your content. The article has really peaks my interest. I’m going to bookmark your website and maintain checking for new information.
I think other website proprietors should take this site as an model, very clean and excellent user friendly style and design, let alone the content. You are an expert in this topic!
One other issue is when you are in a situation where you will not have a cosigner then you may want to try to exhaust all of your federal funding options. You will find many awards and other scholarships and grants that will present you with money to help with classes expenses. Thanks alot : ) for the post.
bulk alnico magnets
You can definitely see your skills in the work you write. The world hopes for more passionate writers like you who aren’t afraid to say how they believe. Always follow your heart.
I like the efforts you have put in this, thanks for all the great content.
I like what you guys are up too. Such intelligent work and reporting! Keep up the superb works guys I’ve incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I think it will improve the value of my site 🙂
I really appreciate this post. I have been looking everywhere for this! Thank goodness I found it on Bing. You have made my day! Thank you again!
You could certainly see your enthusiasm in the work you write. The sector hopes for more passionate writers such as you who are not afraid to say how they believe. At all times follow your heart.
Pozycjonowanie Stron Internetowych Gorzow
I really enjoy looking through on this website, it contains superb content. “One should die proudly when it is no longer possible to live proudly.” by Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche.
There is clearly a lot to identify about this. I feel you made certain good points in features also.
Merely wanna comment on few general things, The website design and style is perfect, the written content is real superb : D.
pembesar penis alami
F*ckin’ amazing things here. I am very glad to see your post. Thanks a lot and i am looking forward to contact you. Will you please drop me a e-mail?
There are some interesting time limits in this article however I don’t know if I see all of them center to heart. There’s some validity but I will take hold opinion until I look into it further. Good article , thanks and we would like more! Added to FeedBurner as properly
Comments are closed.