Disclosure of Medical Records and Privacy Concerns in ICBC Injury Claims
Reasons for judgement were published this week on the BC Supreme Court Website dealing with disclosure of past medical records in the context of an ICBC Injury Claim.
In this week’s case (Sidhu v. Dhani) the Plaintiff was involved in a 2006 BC Car Crash and sued for damages. In the course of the lawsuit ICBC asked that the Plaintiff provide all her medical records for 4 years before the car crash. There was evidence that the Plaintiff attended one specific GP 236 times in the years before the collision. The Plaintiff refused to produce these records and ICBC applied to court. At the hearing the Master largely agreed with ICBC and ordered that the medical practitioners who treated the Plaintiff produce all of their records for the 3 years before the car crash directly to ICBC’s lawyer.
The Plaintiff appealed arguing that the disclosure should not have been ordered or, in the alternative, that the records should go to the Plaintiff’s lawyer first so that clearly irrelevant records could be redacted before sharing the records with ICBC.
On Appeal Mr. Justice Schultes agreed that the the records should be produced but ordered that they be produced with the safeguards the Plaintiff wished.
In coming to this decision Mr. Justice Schultes reasoned as follows:
 The learned master ordered the production of the records in what has become known as Jones form, that is, directly to counsel for the third party rather than in so-called Halliday form, in which the plaintiff’s counsel would first have the opportunity to review the records and seek to vet out any matters said to be irrelevant or subject to a privilege. The learned master did not provide the reasoning underlying this aspect of his decision…
the master drew the inference that the sheer number of medical visits, including the remarkable number to one doctor, made it likely that the clinical records contained information that would be relevant to the plaintiff’s claims. The learned master’s reasons, though brief, clearly demonstrate that process of analysis. In particular, the large number of medical visits would be relevant to the plaintiff’s claim that the accident had diminished his employment prospects and ability to earn future income by suggesting some other chronic or ongoing difficulties potentially unrelated to the accident.
 To make this distinction clear, it appears to me that speculation and so-called fishing expeditions refer to a situation in which the material in support of an application does not give rise to a reasonable inference that material relating to the matter is likely in the hands of the third party. Material relating to the matter is, of course, that which directly or indirectly allows a party to advance his own case or damage that of his adversary’s: Compagnie Financiere et Commerciale du Pacifique v. Peruvian Guano Co. (1882), 11 Q.B.D. 55 (C.A.) which is the standard reference on this point.
 It follows that I find that the learned master was not clearly wrong in his decision on this aspect of the case and I would therefore dismiss the first part of the appeal…
 The plaintiff further argues that even if the learned master was not clearly wrong in ordering disclosure of these records, he erred to that standard in failing to order their disclosure on the so-called Halliday basis, that is, released first to him so that issues of relevancy and privilege could be considered. The source of this basis is the decision ofHalliday v. McCulloch (1986), 1 B.C.L.R. (2d) 194 (C.A.).
 The value of the Halliday process is to allow potentially privileged material to be preserved until a proper determination of its status has been made and to allow the plaintiff to delete irrelevant or embarrassing or confidential material, or to make it irrelevant by amending his pleadings before discovery: see Halliday, at pages 199 and 200. The effectiveness of this process, of course, depends on counsel carrying out their duty to disclose relevant material: see Boxer v. Reesor (1983), 43 B.C.L.R. 352 (S.C.). However, as Lambert J.A. pointed out in Halliday any abuse of this method of disputing relevance can be subsequently punished by an order of costs.
 On this issue, the plaintiff relies on Grewal v. Hospedales, (2004), 33 B.C.L.R. (4th) 294 (C.A.), and Gibson v. Mian, 2002 BCSC 1836.
 In Grewal, the master was found to have erred in failing to consider in a personal injury accident the relevance of the plaintiff’s medical records from specialist whose areas of specialty appeared to bear no relationship to the types of claims that the plaintiff was advancing.
 In Gibson, the master ordered medical records of the plaintiff’s family doctor in Halliday form based on the reasoning that such a doctor is likely to deal with irrelevant issues that could embarrass the plaintiff. This analysis was as applicable, in the master’s view, to male plaintiffs as to female plaintiffs. As the master observed:
… in the case of general practitioners, other things being equal, I think that … describing them as the general practitioner with a history of consultations for matters other than the injuries sustained in the accident is enough to meet the necessary standard of lack of relevance and embarrassment.
 The Gibson decision, being a decision of a master, is not, strictly speaking, binding on me, but I do find its analysis helpful. While I would not go so far as to say that in all cases the bare assertion that a doctor is a general practitioner who did not treat the injuries complained of as part of the action will justify disclosure on a Halliday format, I do think that it would raise concerns that a court must at least consider and address. In this regard, I disagree with the third party’s submission that the Halliday procedure is restricted to circumstances, like those in Grewal, in which the nature of the practitioner’s speciality is on its face irrelevant to the issues in the litigation.
 Here, the learned master did not provide any analysis explaining his decision to order disclosure in Jones format. While he is deemed to know the law and to have applied it correctly in the absence of some contrary indication, I think it was a clear error for him not to have identified that the same large number of medical visits which had made it likely that these records contained relevant evidence also sharply increased the risk of capturing irrelevant and embarrassing information during the process. This seems to me to be the obvious corollary of his disclosure decision and I cannot infer that he addressed it and resolved it in a manner that justified Jones disclosure in the absence of any indication to that effect.
 Accordingly, I will allow the appeal to the extent of ordering that records of the doctors whom the plaintiff asserted did not treat him for any matters related to the accident that is the subject matter of this litigation will be disclosed in accordance with the procedure in Halliday.
I should point out that as of July, 2010 the new BC Supreme Court Civil Rules come into force and the tests for what types of documents need to be exchanged will be narrower so it will be interesting to see how this area of law changes under the soon to be in place new system.
Halliday, icbc injury claims, Jones, Mr. Justice Schultes, production of pre accident records, Sidhu v. Dhani
I got what you mean , regards for posting .Woh I am glad to find this website through google. “Success is dependent on effort.” by Sophocles.
fotograf slubny Wadowice
I like what you guys are up too. Such clever work and reporting! Carry on the superb works guys I’ve incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I think it will improve the value of my web site 🙂
Excellent website. A lot of helpful information here. I am sending it to some pals ans also sharing in delicious. And certainly, thanks to your sweat!
I really like your writing style, excellent information, thankyou for putting up : D.
hello!,I really like your writing so so much! proportion we be in contact extra about your post on AOL? I require a specialist on this space to unravel my problem. Maybe that is you! Having a look forward to look you.
Hey! I know this is somewhat off topic but I was wondering which blog platform are you using for this website? I’m getting fed up of WordPress because I’ve had problems with hackers and I’m looking at alternatives for another platform. I would be fantastic if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.
There is noticeably a bundle to find out about this. I assume you made certain good points in options also.
Good – I should definitely pronounce, impressed with your web site. I had no trouble navigating through all the tabs as well as related information ended up being truly easy to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it at all. Reasonably unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or something, web site theme . a tones way for your client to communicate. Excellent task..
The core of your writing while sounding reasonable at first, did not really work very well with me personally after some time. Someplace throughout the sentences you managed to make me a believer unfortunately just for a while. I however have got a problem with your jumps in assumptions and one would do well to fill in all those gaps. In the event that you actually can accomplish that, I will definitely be impressed.
agen poker online
Wow that was unusual. I just wrote an incredibly long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t appear. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that over again. Anyway, just wanted to say excellent blog!
I precisely desired to say thanks once more. I do not know what I would’ve gone through in the absence of these concepts revealed by you relating to this concern. It actually was the daunting scenario for me, but taking a look at a new specialised strategy you resolved it took me to leap for gladness. I am thankful for your assistance and in addition trust you find out what a great job that you’re providing teaching the rest with the aid of a site. Most likely you’ve never come across all of us.
I truly appreciate this post. I have been looking all over for this! Thank goodness I found it on Bing. You’ve made my day! Thx again!
Digital Marketing Manager Wien
Onine Marketing Manager Wien
Admiring the persistence you put into your website and detailed information you provide. It’s nice to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same unwanted rehashed material. Excellent read! I’ve bookmarked your site and I’m adding your RSS feeds to my Google account.
I really appreciate this post. I have been looking everywhere for this! Thank goodness I found it on Bing. You’ve made my day! Thx again!
Here are several of the web-sites we advise for our visitors.
Awsome website! I am loving it!! Will come back again. I am bookmarking your feeds also.
lifeguard courses near me
Hey there! This post couldn’t be written any better! Reading this post reminds me of my previous room mate! He always kept chatting about this. I will forward this post to him. Fairly certain he will have a good read. Thanks for sharing!
It’s actually a great and helpful piece of information. I am happy that you just shared this useful information with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.
I’ve been absent for a while, but now I remember why I used to love this blog. Thanks, I will try and check back more frequently. How frequently you update your web site?
Just wanna say that this is very helpful , Thanks for taking your time to write this.
naturally like your web-site but you need to check the spelling on several of your posts. Many of them are rife with spelling issues and I in finding it very troublesome to inform the truth nevertheless I’ll definitely come again again.
I do trust all the concepts you’ve introduced on your post. They are really convincing and will certainly work. Still, the posts are too short for starters. May just you please lengthen them a little from next time? Thanks for the post.
websites to watch game of thrones free
I do agree with all the ideas you have presented in your post. They’re really convincing and will definitely work. Still, the posts are very short for starters. Could you please extend them a little from next time? Thanks for the post.
I’ve been exploring for a little bit for any high quality articles or blog posts on this kind of area . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this site. Reading this information So i am happy to convey that I have a very good uncanny feeling I discovered exactly what I needed. I most certainly will make sure to don’t forget this site and give it a glance regularly.
Opieka Osob Starszych Praca
Thank you for the sensible critique. Me and my neighbor were just preparing to do a little research about this. We got a grab a book from our area library but I think I learned more from this post. I am very glad to see such wonderful info being shared freely out there.
Hey there, I think your website might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your blog site in Opera, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, superb blog!
You have brought up a very fantastic details , regards for the post.
ball hard dj taydeville ft crime mob free
Dead composed written content , thankyou for information .
Every as soon as inside a though we decide on blogs that we read. Listed below would be the latest internet sites that we opt for.
I just couldn’t depart your web site prior to suggesting that I actually enjoyed the standard information a person provide for your visitors? Is gonna be back often in order to check up on new posts
best blow job tricks
just beneath, are many entirely not associated sites to ours, even so, they are certainly worth going over
Familienfoto St. Gallen
whoah this weblog is great i love studying your posts. Keep up the great work! You understand, lots of persons are hunting around for this information, you could aid them greatly.
Profesjonalne Pozycjonowanie Strony Gorzow
Usually I don’t learn article on blogs, however I wish to say that this write-up very pressured me to check out and do so! Your writing style has been surprised me. Thanks, quite great post.
very couple of internet websites that transpire to be comprehensive beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly properly really worth checking out
At this time it seems like Movable Type is the best blogging platform out there right now. (from what I’ve read) Is that what you’re using on your blog?
I’ve been exploring for a bit for any high-quality articles or blog posts on this kind of area . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this web site. Reading this info So i am happy to convey that I have an incredibly good uncanny feeling I discovered exactly what I needed. I most certainly will make sure to do not forget this web site and give it a glance on a constant basis.
pembesar alat vital alami
Great goods from you, man. I have understand your stuff previous to and you’re just extremely great. I really like what you have acquired here, really like what you are stating and the way in which you say it. You make it enjoyable and you still take care of to keep it sensible. I can’t wait to read far more from you. This is actually a great site.
one of our guests recently proposed the following website
Comments are closed.