ICBC Denied Double Costs Despite Significantly Besting Formal Settlement Offer

(Update February 9, 2012 – the below decision is under appeal with the BCCA granting leave to appeal on February 9, 2012)

Last year highly publicized reasons for judgement were released assessing damages at $5.9 million for a lawyer who sustained a traumatic brain injury during a dance floor incident.   Despite the headline making award, only a fraction of the damages were recoverable due to the limits of the responsible insurer.  In what may be the final chapter of this long legal saga, reasons for judgement were released addressing costs.
As was widely reported, the Plaintiff was injured in a dance floor incident and successfully sued another lawyer that knocked her down causing her brain injury.  The reason why ICBC played a role is because the Plaintiff was involved in a subsequent car crash.  She sued the motorist for damages claiming the crash aggravated her brain injury.  Prior to trial ICBC made a formal settlement offer of $500,000.  The Plaintiff countered at $1.9 million.   Ultimately her allegations that the crash aggravated the brain injury were rejected and damages of just over $10,000 were awarded for the car crash.
ICBC asked the the Court to award them double costs under Rule 9-1.  Despite ICBC’s success in relation to their formal settlement offer and despite concerns about aspects of the Plaintiff’s trial testimony, Mr. Justice Kelleher declined to award ICBC double costs.  In today’s case (Danicek v. Li) the Court provided the following reasons:
[38] Considering all the factors, I conclude that there should be no award of double costs.  The plaintiff suffered, I found, career ending injuries.  I cannot say it was unreasonable to decline the offer.  Although I considered Ms. Danicek to be less than candid, I conclude on a consideration of all factors that no double costs award should be made.
Despite this, the Court did go on to award Costs and Disbursements at Scale C (the highest scale).  In reaching this decision Mr. Justice Kelleher provided the following Reasons:

[40] Counsel agree that the relevant factors for determining whether Scale C costs should be awarded include:

–       the length of trial;

–       the complexity of issues involved;

–       the number and the complexity of pre-trial applications;

–       whether the action was hard fought with little conceded;

–       the number and length of examinations for discovery;

–       the number and complexity of expert reports; and

–       the extent of the effort required in the collection and proof of facts.

See: Mort v. Saanich School Board, 2001 BCSC 1473 at para. 6; 566935 B.C. Ltd. v. Allianz Insurance Co. of Canada, 2005 BCSC 3032 at para. 7.

[41] Based on these criteria, there will be an award at Scale C.

[42] The trial was 29 days.  A central issue was whether the plaintiff’s symptoms would have resolved but for the motor vehicle accident.  There were reports and/or testimony from physiatrists, neurologists, psychiatrists and others.  The plaintiff alone relied on 21 expert reports.

[43] The action was complex. There were some seven parties involved. The plaintiff was examined for discovery on eleven occasions over several years. There were a number of applications both prior to and during the trial.  This case bears similarity to Graham v. Marek, 2002 BCSC 214; Ramcharitar v. Gill, 2007 BCSC 1268; and Mosher v. Sedens Estate, [1998] B.C.J. No. 2822.

[44] I have considered Hussack v. School District No. 33 (Chilliwack), 2010 BCSC 304, and Radke, when costs at Scale B were awarded.

[45] Hussack was a 23-day trial.  However, the liability issue was not complex; there were only four pre-trial applications and none was complicated.  The examination for discovery of the plaintiff was one full day and three half days.  There was one plaintiff and one defendant.

[46] In Radke, Madam Justice Boyd cited these circumstances in concluding that the matter was not a matter of “more than ordinary difficulty” (at para. 26):

[26]      The one circumstance which I agree made this case somewhat unusual was the fact that the defendant apparently took a very heavy interest in this case, to the point of following her neighbour (the plaintiff) about and gathering evidence to challenge her claims of disability.  In response the plaintiff’s counsel apparently conducted an in- depth investigation of the defendant, including her history of unusual behaviour in the neighbourhood, so as to challenge her own credibility and reliability.  The trial was settled before that evidence was heard.

[47] The complexity of this matter is well beyond what was before the Court in Hussack and Radke.


Appendix B, costs, Danicek v. Alexander Holburn Beaudin & Lang, Danicek v. Li, Mr. Justice Kelleher, Rule 9, Rule 9-1, Rule 9-1(5), Rule 9-1(6), Scale C Costs

Comments (45)

  • I simply want to tell you that I’m newbie to weblog and truly loved your web page. Likely I’m going to bookmark your site . You actually come with remarkable posts. Kudos for sharing with us your blog site.

  • Thanks for the sensible critique. Me and my neighbor were just preparing to do some research on this. We got a grab a book from our area library but I think I learned more from this post. I am very glad to see such magnificent information being shared freely out there.

  • Fantastic website. Plenty of useful information here. I’m sending it to a few pals ans also sharing in delicious. And naturally, thanks to your effort!

  • Hello There. I found your weblog the usage of msn. That is a very neatly written article. I will make sure to bookmark it and come back to read more of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I’ll certainly comeback.

  • Excellent beat ! I would like to apprentice even as you amend your website, how could i subscribe for a weblog website? The account aided me a acceptable deal. I had been tiny bit acquainted of this your broadcast provided shiny transparent idea

  • Thank you for another wonderful article. Where else could anyone get that kind of information in such an ideal way of writing? I’ve a presentation next week, and I am on the look for such information.

  • Hi just wanted to give you a brief heads up and let you know a few of the pictures aren’t loading correctly. I’m not sure why but I think its a linking issue. I’ve tried it in two different web browsers and both show the same outcome.

  • Whoa! This blog looks exactly like my old one! It’s on a entirely different topic but it has pretty much the same layout and design. Outstanding choice of colors!

  • Just about all of what you state is supprisingly legitimate and that makes me ponder the reason why I hadn’t looked at this in this light previously. Your piece really did switch the light on for me personally as far as this subject matter goes. However at this time there is one position I am not necessarily too comfortable with so while I make an effort to reconcile that with the actual central theme of the position, let me observe what the rest of the visitors have to say.Well done.

  • I just could not depart your site prior to suggesting that I actually enjoyed the standard information a person provide for your visitors? Is going to be back often in order to check up on new posts

  • Attractive component to content. I just stumbled upon your web site and in accession capital to assert that I get in fact enjoyed account your weblog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing in your feeds and even I achievement you get right of entry to persistently rapidly.

  • One thing is always that one of the most typical incentives for using your card is a cash-back as well as rebate offer. Generally, you’re going to get 1-5 back in various expenditures. Depending on the cards, you may get 1 back on most expenses, and 5 back again on purchases made from convenience stores, gas stations, grocery stores and also ‘member merchants’.

  • Thanks for the recommendations shared on the blog. Something also important I would like to mention is that weight reduction is not about going on a dietary fad and trying to lose as much weight that you can in a few days. The most effective way to burn fat is by using it slowly and using some basic recommendations which can help you to make the most through your attempt to lose fat. You may understand and already be following a few of these tips, but reinforcing expertise never affects.

  • I think other website proprietors should take this web site as an model, very clean and excellent user genial style and design, as well as the content. You’re an expert in this topic!

  • Hey very cool web site!! Man .. Beautiful .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your blog and take the feeds also…I’m happy to find a lot of useful information here in the post, we need develop more strategies in this regard, thanks for sharing. . . . . .

  • Simply wish to say your article is as amazing. The clarity in your post is just great and i can assume you are an expert on this subject. Well with your permission let me to grab your RSS feed to keep up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please continue the gratifying work.

  • Somebody essentially help to make seriously posts I would state. This is the very first time I frequented your web page and thus far? I surprised with the research you made to create this particular publish amazing. Fantastic job!

  • I simply couldn’t leave your website prior to suggesting that I really enjoyed the standard information an individual provide for your visitors? Is gonna be back incessantly to investigate cross-check new posts

  • Interesting article. It is quite unfortunate that over the last ten years, the travel industry has already been able to to take on terrorism, SARS, tsunamis, bird flu, swine flu, along with the first ever real global economic collapse. Through it the industry has really proven to be sturdy, resilient along with dynamic, acquiring new tips on how to deal with trouble. There are constantly fresh challenges and the opportunity to which the market must yet again adapt and reply.

  • I like what you guys are up also. Such intelligent work and reporting! Keep up the excellent works guys I have incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I think it’ll improve the value of my website :).

  • I want to show my passion for your generosity supporting people who require help with that question. Your special commitment to passing the message up and down became unbelievably practical and have helped workers like me to get to their desired goals. Your personal important facts means a whole lot a person like me and a whole lot more to my mates. With thanks; from each one of us.

  • One thing is that one of the most common incentives for applying your cards is a cash-back or rebate offer. Generally, you’ll have access to 1-5 back in various expenditures. Depending on the cards, you may get 1 again on most expenses, and 5 back on buying made going to convenience stores, gas stations, grocery stores and ‘member merchants’.

  • Excellent blog here! Also your site loads up fast! What host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my website loaded up as fast as yours lol

  • Hey just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The words in your content seem to be running off the screen in Ie. I’m not sure if this is a format issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I figured I’d post to let you know. The style and design look great though! Hope you get the problem fixed soon. Many thanks

  • What i don’t realize is in truth how you are not really a lot more neatly-preferred than you might be now. You’re so intelligent. You already know therefore significantly when it comes to this topic, made me in my view believe it from so many numerous angles. Its like women and men aren’t interested until it is something to do with Lady gaga! Your personal stuffs excellent. Always take care of it up!

  • I not to mention my friends were found to be looking through the nice techniques on your web page while immediately developed a terrible feeling I never thanked the website owner for those tips. Those young boys happened to be absolutely joyful to read them and have in effect actually been tapping into those things. I appreciate you for actually being quite kind and then for pick out these kinds of fabulous themes millions of individuals are really desirous to be informed on. Our sincere regret for not expressing gratitude to sooner.

  • This web page can be a walk-by way of for all the info you needed about this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse here, and also you’ll definitely discover it.

  • Thanks for the sensible critique. Me and my neighbor were just preparing to do some research about this. We got a grab a book from our area library but I think I learned more clear from this post. I am very glad to see such great information being shared freely out there.

Comments are closed.

Contact

If you would like further information or require assistance, please get in touch.

ERIK
MAGRAKEN

Personal Injury Lawyer

When not writing the BC Injury Law Blog, Erik is the managing partner at MacIsaac & Company, based in Victoria, B.C. He is also involved with combative sports regulatory issues and authors the Combat Sports Law Blog.

“Work hard, be kind and enjoy the ride!”
Erik’s Philosophy

Disclaimer