A Great Rule 37-B Precedent – Reality of Insurance in ICBC Claims Discussed

Reasons for Judgement delivered by Madam Justice Dorgan on July 30, 2009 were recently transcribed and have come to my attention applying Rule 37B in a favourable way to a Plaintiff who failed to beat an ICBC formal offer of settlement.
In this case (Robbeson v. Gibson) the Plaintiff was injured in a BC Motor Vehicle Collision.  The Defendant (insured by ICBC) made a formal offer of $82,100 under Rule 37B.  At trial the Jury awarded the Plaintiff $52,700 for damages.  In other words, ICBC beat their formal settlement offer.
The defendant (through ICBC) brought a motion seeking to deprive the Plaintiff of her costs from the date of the formal offer forward and further seeking to have the Plaintiff pay the Defendant’s costs and disbursements from the date of the formal offer forward.  Such an order is not unusual when ICBC beats a formal offer at trial.  If this motion was granted the punishing effect would in essence leave the Plaintiff with $0 as the costs consequences would eat up almost the entire $52,700 awarded by the Jury.
Madam Justice Dorgan refused to grant the Defendant’s application and instead ordered that the Plaintiff ‘be deprived of all tariff items to which she would otherwise be entitled‘ from a few weeks following the delivery of the formal offer through trial and further awarding the Plaintiff to ‘all disbursements incurred from the comencement of the action to the conclusion of trial‘.
In reaching this conclusion Madam Justice Dorgan made some important comments when applying Rule 37B which I highlight below:
On the topic of the purpose of Rule 37B the Court stated  “the cost consequence (of Rule 37B) is meant to encourage litigants to reach settlements; reasonable settlements, and to impose penalties on those litigants who decline to accept offers which are reasonable in all of the circumstances...”
In considering “the relationship between the offer and the final judgement” the Court held that the gap between $80,000 and $52,000 was not ‘dramatically divergent’.  Specifically Madam Justice Dorgan noted that “the swing is not wild…the relationship between the offer and the award is, in my view, a neutral factor on the question of costs‘.  In coming to this conclusion it was noted that “the overall award clearly reflects the jury’s conclusion that the plaintiff was injured as a result of the defendant’s negligence and that she suffered losses, both non-pecuniary and pecuniary“.
When considering the relative financial circumstances of the parties the Court seems to have considered the fact that the Defendant was insured by ICBC.  Judgements to date are still inconsistent in determining whether a policy of insurance is a relevant consideration under Rule 37B.  Madam Justice Dorgan did not ignore the reality that this case was defended by ICBC through a policy of insurance as opposed to directly financed by the Defendant.  Addressing this issue the court noted as follows “the defendant’s financial position is unknown.  While he testified, he did not actively involve himself in this litigation.  ICBC defended the case.  I have no need to, nor should I, go into a comparison of the financial circumstances of a corporate citizen versus a private citizen, but each of the two citizens is entitled to competent counsel, entitled to pursue their claim on the basis of advice received by each of those counsel, and that is what happened here.  On the issue of financial circumstances, I am advised that the jury award, as I have earlier said, will be effectively cancelled if the defendant obtains a costs order from the date of the offer to the conclusion of trial…It is reasonable for me to conclude that (the plaintiff) has significant disbursements from prosecuting her claim.  Certainly, the trial disbursements would be significant.  In all those circumstances, this factor, I am satisfied, favours the Plaintiff

financial postition of the parties, formal settlement offers, ICBC beating formal offer at trial, icbc injury claims, Madam Justice Dorgan, Robbeson v. Gibson, Rule 37B, tort claims

Comments (48)

  • I simply want to say I’m newbie to blogs and really liked this page. Very likely I’m want to bookmark your blog post . You definitely come with fantastic article content. Cheers for sharing your webpage.

  • Aw, this was a really nice post. In concept I wish to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and precise effort to make a very good article… however what can I say… I procrastinate alot and in no way seem to get one thing done.

  • Hello There. I found your blog using msn. This is a very well written article. I will be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I’ll definitely comeback.

  • Very interesting details you have noted , thankyou for putting up. “What is harder than rock, or softer than water Yet soft water hollows out hard rock. Persevere.” by Ovid.

  • I’m impressed, I need to say. Really hardly ever do I encounter a weblog that’s both educative and entertaining, and let me tell you, you’ve gotten hit the nail on the head. Your idea is outstanding; the problem is one thing that not sufficient people are talking intelligently about. I’m very blissful that I stumbled across this in my seek for one thing relating to this.

  • Hi there very cool web site!! Guy .. Beautiful .. Superb .. I will bookmark your website and take the feeds additionally…I’m satisfied to find so many useful info here within the submit, we’d like develop more strategies on this regard, thanks for sharing. . . . . .

  • You really make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this matter to be really something that I think I would never understand. It seems too complicated and very broad for me. I am looking forward for your next post, I will try to get the hang of it!

  • Hello my friend! I want to say that this post is awesome, nice written and include almost all significant infos. I would like to see more posts like this.

  • I was more than happy to seek out this net-site.I needed to thanks in your time for this excellent learn!! I positively enjoying each little little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you weblog post.

  • Excellent post. I was checking constantly this blog and I am impressed! Extremely useful information particularly the last part 🙂 I care for such information a lot. I was seeking this certain info for a very long time. Thank you and best of luck.

  • Thank you for the sensible critique. Me and my neighbor were just preparing to do some research on this. We got a grab a book from our local library but I think I learned more clear from this post. I’m very glad to see such fantastic info being shared freely out there.

  • Does your website have a contact page? I’m having trouble locating it but, I’d like to shoot you an email. I’ve got some creative ideas for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great site and I look forward to seeing it expand over time.

  • I carry on listening to the news lecture about getting boundless online grant applications so I have been looking around for the best site to get one. Could you tell me please, where could i find some?

  • Hello would you mind sharing which blog platform you’re using? I’m looking to start my own blog in the near future but I’m having a hard time deciding between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The reason I ask is because your design and style seems different then most blogs and I’m looking for something unique. P.S Sorry for getting off-topic but I had to ask!

  • I am now not positive where you’re getting your info, however good topic. I must spend a while learning more or understanding more. Thanks for excellent info I was on the lookout for this info for my mission.

  • I would like to show my thanks to you just for bailing me out of this situation. As a result of scouting throughout the internet and seeing thoughts that were not productive, I assumed my entire life was done. Living without the presence of answers to the problems you have resolved by means of your article content is a serious case, and the ones which may have negatively affected my entire career if I had not encountered your website. Your main know-how and kindness in controlling everything was tremendous. I’m not sure what I would’ve done if I hadn’t discovered such a thing like this. I am able to at this time look forward to my future. Thanks for your time so much for the high quality and effective help. I won’t be reluctant to propose your web site to anyone who would need counselling about this issue.

  • I would like to thnkx for the efforts you have put in writing this web site. I am hoping the same high-grade web site post from you in the upcoming also. Actually your creative writing abilities has encouraged me to get my own site now. Actually the blogging is spreading its wings fast. Your write up is a great example of it.

  • Thank you for another informative blog. Where else could I get that kind of information written in such a perfect way? I have a project that I am just now working on, and I’ve been on the look out for such info.

  • Thanks for the helpful article. It is also my opinion that mesothelioma cancer has an particularly long latency time, which means that signs and symptoms of the disease would possibly not emerge right up until 30 to 50 years after the preliminary exposure to mesothelioma. Pleural mesothelioma, and that is the most common sort and has effects on the area throughout the lungs, might result in shortness of breath, breasts pains, including a persistent coughing, which may bring about coughing up body.

  • Have you ever considered writing an e-book or guest authoring on other blogs? I have a blog centered on the same topics you discuss and would really like to have you share some stories/information. I know my audience would value your work. If you’re even remotely interested, feel free to shoot me an e-mail.

  • Nice blog here! Also your site loads up fast! What web host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my website loaded up as quickly as yours lol

  • I am really impressed with your writing skills as well as with the layout on your blog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Either way keep up the nice quality writing, it’s rare to see a great blog like this one nowadays..

  • You really make it appear really easy together with your presentation but I find this matter to be actually one thing which I think I might by no means understand. It sort of feels too complicated and extremely broad for me. I’m having a look forward in your subsequent post, I will try to get the grasp of it!

  • I loved as much as you’ll obtain performed right here. The caricature is tasteful, your authored subject matter stylish. nonetheless, you command get bought an impatience over that you would like be handing over the following. unwell certainly come further earlier once more as exactly the same just about very incessantly inside case you protect this increase.

  • I simply couldn’t go away your web site prior to suggesting that I really enjoyed the standard info a person provide on your guests? Is going to be back incessantly in order to check out new posts

Comments are closed.

Contact

If you would like further information or require assistance, please get in touch.

ERIK
MAGRAKEN

Personal Injury Lawyer

When not writing the BC Injury Law Blog, Erik is the managing partner at MacIsaac & Company, based in Victoria, B.C. He is also involved with combative sports regulatory issues and authors the Combat Sports Law Blog.

“Work hard, be kind and enjoy the ride!”
Erik’s Philosophy

Disclaimer