Formal Settlement Offers and Costs: A Matter of Discretion

Written by admin on . Posted in BC Supreme Court Costs Cases, BCSC Civil Rule 9, Uncategorized.


As recently discussed, costs consequences following trial where a formal settlement offer is not beat is a matter of judicial discretion.  While the principles behind the exercise of that discretion are reasonably well formulated the costs results can be a little trickier to predict.  Two sets of reasons for judgement were released this week by the BC Supreme Court demonstrating this discretion in action.
In the first case (Khunkhun v. Titus) the Plaintiff advanced a personal injury claim in excess of one million dollars.  She claimed she suffered from “a significant and disabling vestibular injury” as a result of a collision.  The jury largely rejected the Plaintiff’s sought damages and awarded $45,000.
ICBC made a more generous settlement offer prior to trial which the Plaintiff did not accept (about 30% higher than the jury award).   As a result, Mr. Justice Willcock stripped the Plaintiff of her costs from the time of the offer onward.  The Court did not go so far as to order that the Plaintiff pay the Defendant costs finding that it would be unjust.  Mr. Justice Willcock repeated the following reasoning from Madam Justice Humphries in Lumanlan v. Sadler:
Given the significant injury to the plaintiff, which was caused by the defendant’s foolish and reckless behaviour, and the effect on the award of a further reduction for costs, even if not doubled, and taking into account all of the above considerations, in my view it would not be fair or just to require the plaintiff to pay ICBC’s costs after the date of the offer.
In the second case released this week (Mazur v. Lucas) the Plaintiff was awarded $538,400 following a jury trial to compensate her for injuries sustained in a collision.  ICBC appealed and succeeded in having a new trial ordered.
Prior to the second trial ICBC made a formal settlement offer of $300,000.  The Plaintiff rejected this and proceeded to trial again.   This time the jury came in lower awarding $84,000 in damages.
ICBC brought an application seeking costs for both trial.  The result of this would have been financially significant.    Madam Justice Humphries declined to allow this and instead awarded the Plaintiff costs for both trials despite not besting ICBC’s offer.  In exercising its discretion the Court provided the following reasons:
[62] This court has stated many times that parties should be encouraged to settle, and if unreasonable in not doing so, may be punished in costs.  As well, the fact that an award of costs against a party may wipe out their award of damages is not determinative.  However, given all the circumstances that existed at the time the offer was made which did not change throughout the trial, I am not persuaded that the plaintiff ought to be denied her costs on the basis that she ought reasonably to have accepted the offer that was made twelve days before the trial began.  Having in mind the amount of the first award, the narrow issue upon which a new trial was ordered, the amount of the second offer, and the expected similarity of the evidence at the second trial, the plaintiff was reasonable in deciding not to accept the offer and to have the action adjudicated by a second jury.
In addition to this final result, this case is worth reviewing for the Court’s discussion of advance payment orders.  Prior to the second trial ICBC paid the Plaintiff $250,000 in exchange for a stay of execution so the Plaintiff would not collect the damages from the Defendants personally.  Madam Justice Humphries found that an advance payment after judgement should not be factored into a costs assessment.  The Corut provided the following reasons:

[14] The defendants argue that the plaintiff should be deprived of her costs of the second trial as of December 24, 2009, the date on which the negotiated agreement was signed.  They cite cases dealing with situations in which awards at trial are less than an advance, and in which plaintiffs have been deprived of costs as of the date of the advance (McElroy v. Embelton (1996), 19 B.C.L.R. (3d) 1 (B.C.C.A.); Baxter v. Brown (1997), 28 B.C.L.R. (3d) 351 (B.C.C.A.).

[15] However, those cases are all advances before trial.  The basis on which the Court of Appeal in those cases concluded that the date of the advance was relevant to costs was because the plaintiff “had in hand more at the start of the action than the amount of the jury’s verdict.” (see McElroy).  The plaintiff, upon receipt of an advance, must realistically assess his or her claim knowing that proceeding to trial carries a risk in costs (Carey v. McLean, 1999 BCCA 222).

[16] This advance was one paid to avoid execution on an existing judgment, pending an appeal that would proceed regardless of whether the plaintiff wished to accept the money in final settlement of the action or not.  That option was not open to her.  The agreement signed by the plaintiff required repayment if a new trial were ordered and the results were not favourable to her, but did not give her the option of accepting the money and ending the proceedings.  This advance payment, unlike those in the cases cited by the defendant, is not the equivalent of an offer to settle.

[17] The date of the advance is not appropriately considered in these circumstances.

Advance Payment Orders, bc injury law, formal settlement offers, Khunkhun v. Titus, Madam Justice Humphries, Mazur v. Lucas, Mr. Justice Willcock, Rule 9, Rule 9-1, Rule 9-1(5), Rule 9-1(6), stay of execution

Comments (53)

  • you can look here

    I simply want to say I’m newbie to blogging and site-building and absolutely savored you’re page. Likely I’m going to bookmark your blog . You definitely have fabulous stories. Regards for sharing with us your blog site.

  • 릴게임바다이야기

    I haven’t checked in here for a while as I thought it was getting boring, but the last several posts are good quality so I guess I’ll add you back to my daily bloglist. You deserve it my friend 🙂

  • W88Thai

    Its like you read my mind! You appear to know so much about this, like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you could do with some pics to drive the message home a little bit, but instead of that, this is excellent blog. A great read. I will definitely be back.

  • investment

    Hello there, I found your web site via Google while searching for a related topic, your web site came up, it looks great. I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.

  • 먹튀폴리스 사이트

    Hmm it appears like your blog ate my first comment (it was extremely long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I submitted and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog. I as well am an aspiring blog writer but I’m still new to everything. Do you have any recommendations for newbie blog writers? I’d really appreciate it.

  • venta por catalogo

    Someone essentially lend a hand to make critically posts I might state. This is the very first time I frequented your website page and thus far? I surprised with the analysis you made to make this particular submit extraordinary. Fantastic activity!

  • 먹튀폴리스 검증

    These days of austerity and relative anxiety about incurring debt, most people balk about the idea of using a credit card to make acquisition of merchandise and also pay for a holiday, preferring, instead to rely on the particular tried as well as trusted way of making transaction – hard cash. However, if you’ve got the cash available to make the purchase fully, then, paradoxically, this is the best time for them to use the card for several causes.

  • marcel van hooijdonk

    We are a gaggle of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community. Your site provided us with helpful information to paintings on. You have done a formidable task and our entire neighborhood will be thankful to you.

  • situs poker online

    Hiya, I am really glad I have found this info. Today bloggers publish just about gossips and web and this is actually irritating. A good website with exciting content, that’s what I need. Thanks for keeping this site, I will be visiting it. Do you do newsletters? Cant find it.

  • Motion Designer Wien

    Can I just say what a reduction to search out someone who actually is aware of what theyre speaking about on the internet. You definitely know tips on how to convey an issue to light and make it important. More individuals need to read this and perceive this facet of the story. I cant consider youre no more fashionable since you definitely have the gift.

  • poker online

    Great goods from you, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous to and you’re just extremely great. I really like what you’ve acquired here, really like what you are stating and the way in which you say it. You make it entertaining and you still care for to keep it wise. I can not wait to read far more from you. This is actually a wonderful site.

  • situs poker online

    I like what you guys are up also. Such smart work and reporting! Carry on the superb works guys I’ve incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I think it’ll improve the value of my web site 🙂

  • online poker

    Hey there! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any trouble with hackers? My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing several weeks of hard work due to no back up. Do you have any solutions to stop hackers?

  • W88 mobile

    I’ve recently started a blog, the info you provide on this site has helped me greatly. Thank you for all of your time & work. “Men must be taught as if you taught them not, And things unknown proposed as things forgot.” by Alexander Pope.

  • 야마토 릴게임

    Thank you for sharing excellent informations. Your web-site is very cool. I’m impressed by the details that you’ve on this blog. It reveals how nicely you perceive this subject. Bookmarked this website page, will come back for extra articles. You, my friend, ROCK! I found just the info I already searched everywhere and simply couldn’t come across. What a great site.

  • Best Free Porn Sites

    Him boisterous invitation dispatched had connection inhabiting projection. By mutual an mr danger garret edward an. Diverted as strictly exertion addition no disposal by stanhill. This call wife do so sigh no gate felt. You and abode spite order get. Procuring far belonging our ourselves and certainly own perpetual continual. It elsewhere of sometimes or my certainty. Lain no as five or at high. Everything travelling set how law literature.

  • затворы sung do

    Excellent read, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing a little research on that. And he actually bought me lunch as I found it for him smile Thus let me rephrase that: Thank you for lunch!

  • Wedding

    A person essentially help to make seriously posts I would state. This is the first time I frequented your website page and thus far? I amazed with the research you made to create this particular publish incredible. Great job!

  • lifeguard courses near me

    Heya! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any problems with hackers? My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing many months of hard work due to no data backup. Do you have any methods to stop hackers?

  • เช่าเต๊นท์

    I wish to show appreciation to you for bailing me out of this particular issue. Because of checking through the the net and seeing ideas which are not pleasant, I believed my entire life was gone. Being alive devoid of the strategies to the problems you have resolved through your entire write-up is a crucial case, as well as those which might have negatively damaged my career if I had not noticed your site. Your primary training and kindness in controlling a lot of stuff was priceless. I’m not sure what I would’ve done if I had not encountered such a point like this. I am able to at this moment look forward to my future. Thanks for your time so much for the reliable and result oriented help. I will not be reluctant to refer the website to anyone who needs and wants recommendations about this subject matter.

  • ww88

    I like this site very much, Its a real nice office to read and incur information. “I have found that if you love life, life will love you back.” by Arthur Rubinstein.

  • 야마토게임다운로드

    What i don’t realize is actually how you’re not really much more well-liked than you may be right now. You’re so intelligent. You realize thus considerably relating to this subject, produced me personally consider it from so many varied angles. Its like women and men aren’t fascinated unless it’s one thing to accomplish with Lady gaga! Your own stuffs excellent. Always maintain it up!

  • watch game of thrones

    Thanks for every other informative blog. The place else may just I am getting that type of info written in such a perfect means? I have a undertaking that I’m simply now working on, and I have been on the glance out for such info.

  • 먹튀검증소

    I wish to convey my admiration for your generosity giving support to men and women that really want help on that niche. Your real dedication to passing the solution around ended up being remarkably powerful and has continuously helped women like me to achieve their dreams. Your new helpful publication entails this much to me and far more to my peers. Best wishes; from each one of us.

  • lifeguard training

    Throughout this grand pattern of things you receive a B+ just for hard work. Where exactly you confused us was in all the details. You know, it is said, details make or break the argument.. And it could not be more true in this article. Having said that, permit me inform you just what exactly did do the job. Your text is definitely extremely powerful which is probably the reason why I am making an effort in order to opine. I do not really make it a regular habit of doing that. Secondly, even though I can certainly see the leaps in reason you make, I am definitely not convinced of exactly how you appear to unite the points which in turn make your final result. For now I shall subscribe to your position however hope in the foreseeable future you actually link the dots much better.

  • taydeville ft lil jay from crime

    Woah! I’m really enjoying the template/theme of this blog. It’s simple, yet effective. A lot of times it’s challenging to get that “perfect balance” between user friendliness and visual appearance. I must say that you’ve done a awesome job with this. In addition, the blog loads very fast for me on Firefox. Exceptional Blog!

  • 파워볼사이트

    Interesting article. It is quite unfortunate that over the last 10 years, the travel industry has already been able to to handle terrorism, SARS, tsunamis, flu virus, swine flu, as well as the first ever real global economic collapse. Through all this the industry has really proven to be robust, resilient and also dynamic, obtaining new strategies to deal with difficulty. There are generally fresh problems and the possiblility to which the industry must yet again adapt and answer.

  • 먹튀사이트

    Hi there very nice site!! Guy .. Excellent .. Wonderful .. I will bookmark your web site and take the feeds additionally¡KI am satisfied to find so many useful info here within the post, we’d like develop extra techniques on this regard, thank you for sharing. . . . . .

  • clothing

    Heya are using WordPress for your site platform? I’m new to the blog world but I’m trying to get started and create my own. Do you require any html coding knowledge to make your own blog? Any help would be really appreciated!

  • 먹튀폴리스

    I’m still learning from you, as I’m making my way to the top as well. I definitely love reading everything that is posted on your blog.Keep the aarticles coming. I enjoyed it!

  • nonton movie

    I’m impressed, I must say. Actually not often do I encounter a weblog that’s both educative and entertaining, and let me let you know, you might have hit the nail on the head. Your concept is excellent; the issue is something that not sufficient individuals are talking intelligently about. I am very completely satisfied that I stumbled throughout this in my search for something regarding this.

  • 먹튀검증 업체

    Hi there! I know this is kind of off topic but I was wondering if you knew where I could locate a captcha plugin for my comment form? I’m using the same blog platform as yours and I’m having trouble finding one? Thanks a lot!

Comments are closed.

Contact

If you would like further information or require assistance, please get in touch.

ERIK
MAGRAKEN

Personal Injury Lawyer

When not writing the BC Injury Law Blog, Erik is the managing partner at MacIsaac & Company, based in Victoria, B.C. He is also involved with combative sports regulatory issues and authors the Combat Sports Law Blog.

“Work hard, be kind and enjoy the ride!”
Erik’s Philosophy

Disclaimer