More on Out of Court Statements and Their Use at Trial in ICBC Injury Claims


Further to my two recent articles discussing this topic (these can be found here and here) reasons for judgement were released today by the BC Supreme Court, Kelowna Registry, demonstrating yet again the powerful impact out of court statements can have in an ICBC claim.
In today’s case (Aymont v. Capp) the Plaintiff sustained serious injuries in a 2004 BC motor vehicle collision.  She was driving a Mazda Protege and was exiting a gas station parking lot.  She intended on turning left.  As she entered the roadway the Defendant approached from her left hand side.  A ‘t-bone’ type of collision occurred.
The Plaintiff testified at trial that when the Defendant’s vehicle struck hers she was at a stop and her vehicle had not entered the roadway and was “two feet before the fog line“.  The Defendant disagreed and testified that as he approached the gas station the Plaintiff pulled her vehicle into his lane of travel leaving inadequate time to avoid the collision.
During trial the Plaintiff was confronted with various out of Court statements attributed to her where she discussed the collision.  These included statements given to ICBC, a police officer and a chiropractor.  These previous statements were summarized as follows by Madam Justice Gropper:

[9]             The day following the accident, May 15, 2004, Ms. Aymont went for treatment to her chiropractor’s office, Dr. Susan Holroyd.  She says that she felt dizzy and nauseous, disoriented and in a great deal of pain that morning.

[10]         Dr. Holroyd produced her clinical records, which included a “motor vehicle accident history” form.  Ms. Aymont says that she does not recall the form or filling it out.  She cannot recall if it is her handwriting on the form or not.  The handwritten notations (in italics)  on the form state, in relation to the accident:

State How Accident Happened in your own words.

I had stopped at the entrance of gas st. looked both ways saw no one and began onto road – was hit by a truck travelling very fast.

Where you stopped Yes/No?

No [circled]

Estimate your speed?

10 km/h

Brakes on Yes/No?

No [circled]…

[13]         Cst. Rudy Andreucci telephoned Ms. Aymont the day following the accident and they arranged to meet on Sunday, May 16, 2004 at the RCMP Detachment in Westbank.  Cst. Andreucci testified that the purpose of the meeting was to give Ms. Aymont a traffic violation ticket. Cst. Andreucci served a violation ticket on Ms. Aymont for a breach of s. 176(2) of the Motor Vehicle Act: emerging vehicle: failure to yield.  He noted on the reverse side of the ticket what Ms. Aymont said to him:

04-5-16 V.T issued at office dri Nancy Aymont advised she just didn’t see him.  She knows better-than go on without being sure….

[15]         On May 21, 2004, Ms. Aymont met with Mr. Bonner of the Insurance Corporation of British Columbia (“ICBC”) at his office.  Mr. Bonner is a bodily injury adjuster.  He was the adjuster assigned to Ms. Aymont’s file.  Another adjuster was assigned to Mr. Capp’s file.  Mr. Bonner said that he asked questions and typed the answers into the ICBC note taking system on his computer.  He prepared a sketch based on the information provided to him by Ms. Aymont.  In the statement Mr. Bonner recorded Ms. Aymont stating:

I looked to my right first, and then the left and Bartley Road was vacant, and I thought to myself how often does that happen on a Friday afternoon.  After looking right, then left, I looked right again, and that is the last thing I remember…  If the other driver wasn’t going so fast he probably could have stopped.  My husband drove the road the next day.  At the 50 km/h speed limit, and stopped without skidding before the driveway… I was knocked out and can’t say how far I pulled forward from the exit onto Bartley Road before being hit.

[16]         Ms. Aymont also provided a rough sketch showing where the vehicles were as she approached the exit.

[17]         Ms. Aymont does not recall saying “I can’t say how far I pulled out from the exit onto Bartley before being hit.”

[18]         Mr. Bonner produced a hard copy of the statement for Ms. Aymont to review.  She thought that the second page statement was “all mixed up.”  Ms. Aymont says she made certain corrections to the statement in handwriting.  The last sentence of the statement is “I have nothing to add to this statement, which is true to the best of my memory.”  Ms. Aymont signed the statement….

The Court ultimately rejected the Plaintiff’s evidence and accepted the Defendant’s.  This verdict was largely reached based on the Plaintiff’s prior statements.  Madam Justice Gropper gave the following useful reasons demonstrating the damage that can be done with ‘prior inconsistent statements‘:

[77]         Mr. Capp’s evidence that the Aymont vehicle was moving when he first observed it is consistent with the statements that Ms. Aymont made to her chiropractor.  In the form that she completed, or directed Dr. Holroyd to complete, she says that she was not stopped and was moving at about 10 km/hour.  In her statement to Cst. Andreucci she stated that she just did not see Mr. Capp’s vehicle.  She told Mr. Bonner that she had pulled forward from the exit onto Bartley Road before being hit.  All of these statements are consistent with the circumstances that Mr. Capp describes.

[78]         I find as a fact that Ms. Aymont was not stopped “well before the fog line”.  She was moving from the exit into the southbound lane of travel on Bartley Road.  She was going slowly, likely less than 10 km/hour.  Her foot was not on the brake.  She was not looking in the direction of the oncoming traffic, but was engaged in a conversation with her son Joel who was sitting in the passenger seat, and had turned her face toward him to talk about his drink.

[79]          Ms. Aymont did not yield the right of way to Mr. Capp who was the dominant driver. …

[82] In all of the circumstances, I find the plaintiff is 100% at fault for this accident.

This case is also worth reviewing for the Court’s discussion of the duties of expert witnesses.  Both the Plaintiff and the Defendant retained experts to give accident reconstruction evidence.  The Plaintiff’s expert was soundly criticized for giving evidence as an “advocate” instead of a neutral witness.  The criticism can be found at paragraphs 66-73.

Accident Reconstruction Evidence, Advocate, Aymont v. Capp, Ed D'Aoust, engineering evidence, Expert as Advocate, expert evidence, Madam Justice Gropper, Out of Court Statements, Previous Inconsistent Statements, written statements to ICBC

Comments (52)

  • I just want to say I am just all new to blogging and honestly savored your page. Probably I’m going to bookmark your blog post . You amazingly have really good article content. Thanks a lot for sharing with us your website.

  • Hey there just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The words in your post seem to be running off the screen in Ie. I’m not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I figured I’d post to let you know. The design look great though! Hope you get the issue resolved soon. Cheers

  • Great post. I was checking constantly this weblog and I am impressed! Extremely useful info specifically the final phase 🙂 I handle such info a lot. I was seeking this certain info for a very long time. Thanks and good luck.

  • Thanks for the suggestions shared on your blog. Something else I would like to convey is that weight loss is not about going on a celebrity diet and trying to get rid of as much weight as possible in a couple of weeks. The most effective way to shed weight is by getting it gradually and using some basic ideas which can make it easier to make the most from a attempt to drop some weight. You may be aware and already be following a few of these tips, yet reinforcing awareness never does any damage.

  • hello!,I like your writing so much! share we communicate extra about your article on AOL? I require a specialist on this area to resolve my problem. Maybe that is you! Having a look forward to look you.

  • Awesome blog! Is your theme custom made or did you download it from somewhere? A design like yours with a few simple tweeks would really make my blog stand out. Please let me know where you got your design. Bless you

  • you’re really a good webmaster. The site loading speed is incredible. It seems that you are doing any unique trick. In addition, The contents are masterwork. you’ve done a great job on this topic!

  • It is actually a great and helpful piece of info. I’m happy that you simply shared this helpful info with us. Please stay us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing.

  • I do not even know the way I finished up here, however I assumed this post used to be great. I do not understand who you’re but definitely you’re going to a famous blogger when you aren’t already 😉 Cheers!

  • Spot on with this write-up, I actually assume this website needs much more consideration. I’ll in all probability be again to learn way more, thanks for that info.

  • What i don’t understood is actually how you’re not really much more well-liked than you may be now. You’re very intelligent. You realize therefore significantly relating to this subject, produced me personally consider it from so many varied angles. Its like women and men aren’t fascinated unless it’s one thing to accomplish with Lady gaga! Your own stuffs great. Always maintain it up!

  • It’s really a great and helpful piece of information. I am happy that you just shared this useful info with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.

  • Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read anything like this before. So good to seek out anyone with some original thoughts on this subject. realy thanks for starting this up. this web site is one thing that’s wanted on the internet, someone with a bit originality. helpful job for bringing something new to the internet!

  • Have you ever thought about including a little bit more than just your articles? I mean, what you say is important and everything. But just imagine if you added some great graphics or videos to give your posts more, “pop”! Your content is excellent but with images and video clips, this blog could definitely be one of the greatest in its niche. Amazing blog!

  • Thank you for the sensible critique. Me and my neighbor were just preparing to do a little research on this. We got a grab a book from our area library but I think I learned more from this post. I’m very glad to see such magnificent information being shared freely out there.

  • Hey! Would you mind if I share your blog with my twitter group? There’s a lot of people that I think would really appreciate your content. Please let me know. Thanks

  • Hello there! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a group of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community in the same niche. Your blog provided us beneficial information to work on. You have done a marvellous job!

  • I wish to show my thanks to the writer for bailing me out of this particular instance. As a result of looking through the the web and finding recommendations that were not helpful, I was thinking my entire life was over. Being alive devoid of the answers to the difficulties you have sorted out all through your entire guideline is a crucial case, as well as the kind that would have in a wrong way affected my career if I had not encountered your blog. Your main mastery and kindness in playing with all things was tremendous. I don’t know what I would have done if I had not discovered such a point like this. I can at this point look forward to my future. Thanks a lot very much for your professional and sensible help. I will not think twice to endorse the sites to any person who should get direction on this area.

  • This is very interesting, You’re a very skilled blogger. I have joined your rss feed and look forward to seeking more of your excellent post. Also, I have shared your site in my social networks!

  • Excellent blog right here! Additionally your web site lots up fast! What host are you the use of? Can I get your affiliate hyperlink for your host? I wish my site loaded up as fast as yours lol

  • Hello There. I discovered your blog the usage of msn. That is an extremely well written article. I’ll be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful information. Thank you for the post. I will certainly comeback.

  • You really make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this topic to be actually something which I think I would never understand. It seems too complicated and very broad for me. I’m looking forward for your next post, I will try to get the hang of it!

  • My brother recommended I might like this website. He was entirely right. This post truly made my day. You cann’t imagine simply how much time I had spent for this info! Thanks!

  • I am not sure where you’re getting your information, but great topic. I needs to spend some time learning more or understanding more. Thanks for wonderful information I was looking for this information for my mission.

  • Somebody essentially assist to make significantly posts I’d state. That is the first time I frequented your website page and so far? I amazed with the analysis you made to make this particular publish incredible. Magnificent process!

  • Somebody essentially lend a hand to make critically articles I would state. That is the very first time I frequented your website page and so far? I surprised with the analysis you made to create this actual publish incredible. Wonderful activity!

  • An fascinating dialogue is value comment. I think that you must write more on this subject, it might not be a taboo topic but typically persons are not sufficient to talk on such topics. To the next. Cheers

  • hello!,I really like your writing so so much! proportion we be in contact more about your article on AOL? I need an expert in this area to solve my problem. May be that’s you! Looking forward to peer you.

  • Very great post. I simply stumbled upon your weblog and wanted to mention that I have really loved browsing your blog posts. After all I’ll be subscribing on your feed and I am hoping you write once more very soon!

  • Thanks a lot for the helpful content. It is also my opinion that mesothelioma cancer has an really long latency period of time, which means that signs and symptoms of the disease may not emerge until finally 30 to 50 years after the original exposure to asbestos. Pleural mesothelioma, which can be the most common form and influences the area within the lungs, might result in shortness of breath, upper body pains, along with a persistent coughing, which may bring about coughing up blood vessels.

  • I really like your blog.. very nice colors & theme. Did you make this website yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you? Plz respond as I’m looking to construct my own blog and would like to know where u got this from. cheers

  • Hello just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The words in your post seem to be running off the screen in Chrome. I’m not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with internet browser compatibility but I thought I’d post to let you know. The layout look great though! Hope you get the issue fixed soon. Many thanks

  • Its like you read my thoughts! You seem to know a lot about this, like you wrote the ebook in it or something. I feel that you simply can do with some percent to power the message house a bit, however instead of that, that is excellent blog. A great read. I will definitely be back.

Comments are closed.

Contact

If you would like further information or require assistance, please get in touch.

ERIK
MAGRAKEN

Personal Injury Lawyer

When not writing the BC Injury Law Blog, Erik is the managing partner at MacIsaac & Company, based in Victoria, B.C. He is also involved with combative sports regulatory issues and authors the Combat Sports Law Blog.

“Work hard, be kind and enjoy the ride!”
Erik’s Philosophy

Disclaimer