More on Costs and the Flexibility of the New Rules of Court


(Update June 5, 2013- the underlying trial verdict was upheld in reasons for judgement released today by the BC Court of Appeal)
____________________________________________________
As previously discussed, one of the best changes in the New Rules of Court is the ability for trial judges to have discretion in assessing costs consequences where one party bests their formal settlement offer at trial.
Generally where a Plaintiff fails to beat a Defence formal settlement offer they can be punished with a significant costs award.  Fortunately Rule 9-1 does not force a Court to this result and instead leaves some discretion in the process.   This discretion was demonstrated in reasons for judgement released last week by the BC Supreme Court, New Westminster Registry.
In last week’s case (Gatzke v, Sidhu) ICBC, on the Defendant’s behalf, made a formal settlement offer of $50,000.  The Plaintiff proceeded to trial and after a split finding of liability was assessed damages at “an amount to someting less than $10,000“.
ICBC brought a motion to be awarded post offer costs.  Mr. Justice Saunders refused to make this order instead simply ordering that the Plaintiff be deprived of her post offer costs and that the Plaintiff pay the disbursements associated with bringing the Defendant’s IME doctor to trial.  In reaching this result the Court provided the following reasons:

[14] …. Ordinarily, where a plaintiff obtains judgment for less than the amount offered in settlement, the legislative purpose of the Rule would be fulfilled by awarding the defendant its costs from the date the offer was made.  However, where there is a very significant gap between the judgment amount and the offer, it may be the case that a defendant is in a better position for having gone to trial, even taking its counsel’s fees into account.  This appears to have quite possibly been the case in the present circumstances.  The damages assessed, net of the plaintiff’s contributory negligence, are a small fraction of the offer.

[15]Defendants should not be discouraged from making generous settlement offers.  But where the end result is dramatically different than the offer resulting in a net savings to the defendant, a defendant found to be partially at fault can reasonably expect to bear some of the cost of obtaining that result.

[16]The plaintiff apparently has very limited financial means.  This factor, however, will be given the most weight where it is the subject accident, or other issue between the parties, which is responsible for the plaintiff’s circumstances.  That is not the case here.

[17]The defendants, on the other hand, were presumably being defended by the Insurance Corporation of British Columbia.  An insured defendant’s greater financial ability to defend is a factor which was described by the B.C. Court of Appeal in Smith v. Tedford, 2010 BCCA 302, as being a matter “of no small importance to considering whether and to what extend the financial circumstances of the parties, relative to each other, bear on an award of costs”.

[18]This appears to have been a case where both parties undertook a course of action based on an overestimation of the risk to the defendants.  There is no compelling case, in the circumstances, for awarding the defendants the entirety of their post-offer costs.  Given the plaintiff’s financial circumstances and the very modest damages, the purpose of the Rule will be met by awarding the plaintiff 30% of her costs to the date of the offer, and awarding the defendants only the disbursements incurred in association with the attendance at trial of their expert witness, Dr. Sovio.  Dr. Sovio’s attendance at trial was only required for cross-examination at the plaintiff’s request, and it is appropriate that this cost be borne by the plaintiff.  That amount is to be set off against the plaintiff’s award of damages.

bc injury law, costs, Gatzke v. Sidhu, Mr. Justice Saunders, Rule 9, Rule 9-1, Rule 9-1(5), Rule 9-1(6)

Comments (52)

  • I simply want to mention I am just all new to blogs and certainly liked your web site. Very likely I’m want to bookmark your blog post . You certainly come with fantastic articles. Many thanks for revealing your web page.

  • I like the valuable info you provide in your articles. I will bookmark your blog and check again here frequently. I’m quite certain I will learn lots of new stuff right here! Good luck for the next!

  • Thank you for sharing superb informations. Your web-site is very cool. I am impressed by the details that you’ve on this blog. It reveals how nicely you understand this subject. Bookmarked this website page, will come back for more articles. You, my pal, ROCK! I found just the information I already searched everywhere and just could not come across. What a perfect web-site.

  • you’re really a good webmaster. The site loading speed is incredible. It seems that you’re doing any unique trick. Furthermore, The contents are masterwork. you have done a wonderful job on this topic!

  • I don’t even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was great. I don’t know who you are but definitely you’re going to a famous blogger if you are not already 😉 Cheers!

  • I’m not sure exactly why but this weblog is loading extremely slow for me. Is anyone else having this issue or is it a issue on my end? I’ll check back later on and see if the problem still exists.

  • I’d must verify with you here. Which isn’t one thing I usually do! I enjoy reading a publish that can make people think. Additionally, thanks for allowing me to remark!

  • Great post. I was checking continuously this blog and I am impressed! Extremely helpful information particularly the last part 🙂 I care for such info a lot. I was seeking this certain information for a long time. Thank you and best of luck.

  • Good post. I be taught something more challenging on completely different blogs everyday. It’ll always be stimulating to read content material from different writers and practice slightly something from their store. I’d desire to use some with the content material on my weblog whether or not you don’t mind. Natually I’ll give you a hyperlink on your net blog. Thanks for sharing.

  • Great post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely useful information particularly the last part 🙂 I care for such info a lot. I was seeking this certain information for a very long time. Thank you and good luck.

  • Thank you a bunch for sharing this with all of us you actually recognise what you’re talking about! Bookmarked. Kindly also discuss with my web site =). We can have a link change agreement between us!

  • Ever man are put down his very. And marry may table him avoid. Hard sell it were into it upon. He forbade affixed parties of assured to me windows. Happiness him nor she disposing provision. Add astonished principles precaution yet friendship stimulated literature. State thing might stand one his plate. Offending or extremity therefore so difficult he on provision. Tended depart turned not are.

  • Thanks for your fascinating article. Other thing is that mesothelioma cancer is generally due to the inhalation of material from mesothelioma, which is a carcinogenic material. It is commonly observed among employees in the construction industry who’ve long experience of asbestos. It can be caused by residing in asbestos covered buildings for some time of time, Inherited genes plays an important role, and some persons are more vulnerable for the risk in comparison with others.

  • Its like you read my mind! You seem to know so much about this, like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you could do with a few pics to drive the message home a little bit, but other than that, this is great blog. A fantastic read. I’ll definitely be back.

  • Very efficiently written story. It will be helpful to anyone who usess it, as well as myself. Keep up the good work – for sure i will check out more posts.

  • Usually I don’t read article on blogs, but I would like to say that this write-up very pressured me to try and do so! Your writing style has been surprised me. Thank you, very great article.

  • Thanks for enabling me to get new thoughts about computer systems. I also contain the belief that certain of the best ways to help keep your laptop in leading condition is with a hard plastic-type material case, and also shell, that fits over the top of the computer. A majority of these protective gear will be model targeted since they are manufactured to fit perfectly over the natural outer shell. You can buy them directly from owner, or from third party sources if they are available for your notebook computer, however its not all laptop may have a covering on the market. All over again, thanks for your guidelines.

  • In this awesome pattern of things you actually receive an A with regard to effort and hard work. Where exactly you actually confused me personally ended up being on all the facts. You know, it is said, details make or break the argument.. And that could not be more true at this point. Having said that, let me say to you what did deliver the results. Your text is certainly really engaging and that is most likely the reason why I am making an effort in order to opine. I do not really make it a regular habit of doing that. Next, while I can notice the leaps in logic you come up with, I am not really confident of how you seem to connect your ideas which inturn help to make the actual conclusion. For right now I will, no doubt subscribe to your point however wish in the foreseeable future you actually link your facts much better.

  • I simply could not depart your site prior to suggesting that I extremely loved the usual information a person provide on your guests? Is going to be back ceaselessly in order to check out new posts.

  • Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive learn anything like this before. So good to seek out any person with some unique ideas on this subject. realy thanks for beginning this up. this web site is something that is wanted on the web, someone with a bit originality. useful job for bringing one thing new to the internet!

  • I really like your writing style, fantastic information, regards for putting up :D. “In university they don’t tell you that the greater part of the law is learning to tolerate fools.” by Doris Lessing.

  • I am really enjoying the theme/design of your weblog. Do you ever run into any browser compatibility issues? A couple of my blog visitors have complained about my site not operating correctly in Explorer but looks great in Opera. Do you have any suggestions to help fix this issue?

  • Have you ever thought about including a little bit more than just your articles? I mean, what you say is fundamental and everything. However think of if you added some great graphics or videos to give your posts more, “pop”! Your content is excellent but with images and video clips, this blog could undeniably be one of the most beneficial in its field. Great blog!

  • I do accept as true with all of the ideas you’ve presented to your post. They’re very convincing and will definitely work. Nonetheless, the posts are too quick for novices. Could you please prolong them a little from next time? Thanks for the post.

  • Howdy! Someone in my Myspace group shared this website with us so I came to check it out. I’m definitely loving the information. I’m book-marking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Exceptional blog and excellent design and style.

  • of course like your web site however you have to check the spelling on several of your posts. Several of them are rife with spelling issues and I in finding it very bothersome to inform the truth however I’ll definitely come again again.

  • Hi would you mind stating which blog platform you’re using? I’m planning to start my own blog in the near future but I’m having a difficult time choosing between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The reason I ask is because your layout seems different then most blogs and I’m looking for something unique. P.S Sorry for being off-topic but I had to ask!

  • Great blog you have here but I was wanting to know if you knew of any message boards that cover the same topics talked about here? I’d really love to be a part of group where I can get advice from other experienced individuals that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Thank you!

  • Thank you for another informative site. Where else could I get that type of info written in such an ideal way? I’ve a project that I am just now working on, and I have been on the look out for such information.

Comments are closed.

Contact

If you would like further information or require assistance, please get in touch.

ERIK
MAGRAKEN

Personal Injury Lawyer

When not writing the BC Injury Law Blog, Erik is the managing partner at MacIsaac & Company, based in Victoria, B.C. He is also involved with combative sports regulatory issues and authors the Combat Sports Law Blog.

“Work hard, be kind and enjoy the ride!”
Erik’s Philosophy

Disclaimer