BC Injury Claims and Production of Pre Accident Medical Records


Further to my previous post discussing this topic reasons for judgement were released today dealing with the extent of pre-accident record disclosure ICBC (or other defendants) are entitled to when a Plaintiff sues for damages for personal injuries in the BC Supreme Court.
In today’s case (Moukhine v. Collins) the Plaintiff was involved in a 2007 BC car crash.  The Plaintiff sued for damages.  In the Statement of Defence the lawyer plead that the injuries are not the result of an accident, but are were in fact pre-existing conditions.  (This is a rather ‘boilerplate’ pleading raised by the defence in almost every ICBC injury claim).  The defence lawyer then asked that the Plaintiff provide medical records which pre-date the accident by as much as 15 years.
The Court was asked to decide  “whether a mere allegation in a pleading that a plaintiff’s injuries are not the result of an accident, but are caused by his or her pre-accident health condition is enough, without more, to entitle a defendant to production of pre-accident medical records“.
Mr. Justice Harris went on to hold that in personal injury cases, the mere allegation by the Defence lawyer of a pre-existing condition may be enough to compel the disclosure of pre-accident records.  Specifically the Court reasoned as follows:

[18] In my opinion, nothing in Dufault is authority for the proposition that pleadings alone are insufficient to make an order under Rule 26(11) or that evidence is always necessary. Similarly, Dhaliwal does not address the relevance of pleadings as a basis for making a Rule 26(11) order. There is no reference in the judgment  to the issues pleaded in the action and whether pleadings  would have affected the outcome. The case deals only with the sufficiency of the evidence that was before the court. I do not draw from the case the proposition that pleadings standing alone and defining the issues in the action are never a sufficient basis to satisfy the court to make a Rule 26(11) order.

[19] In Marsh v. Parker, 2000 BCSC 1605 at para. 9, Master Horn concluded that Dhaliwal stood for the proposition that “there must be something either by way of evidence or by way of the pleadings which raises the plaintiff’s pre-injury state of health as an issue.”  I agree. Indeed, in Creed v. Dorio, [1998] B.C.J. No. 2479, Mr. Justice Edwards, at paragraph 13, rejected the proposition that “some evidence”  was necessary to establish relevance….

[22] In an appropriate case pleadings  are a sufficient basis on which to exercise a discretion to order production of at least some documents. In some cases it is reasonably obvious that records  may contain relevant (in the sense that term is used in Peruvian Guano) information and should be produced, subject to production following a Jones orHalliday format. Evidence may be required in order to resist a production order. That does not mean, however, that an order will always go on the basis of pleadings alone and it may be premature in some circumstances  to make such an order before discovery (see, for example, Mehdipour v. Shingler (18 March 2009), Vancouver M080517 (S.C.)). Merely pleading pre-existing conditions does not deprive the court of its discretion to refuse to make the order sought when, for example, there is no air of reality about the alleged connection between the documents sought and the issues in the action. Evidence may therefore, on occasion,  be required to establish the relevant connection to overcome the conclusion that the documents are  irrelevant to the claim.

I should point out that as of July, 2010 the new BC Supreme Court Civil Rules come into force and the tests for what types of documents need to be exchanged will be narrower so it will be interesting to see how this area of law changes under the soon to be in place new system.

bc injury claims, disclosure, discovery, icbc injury claims, Moukhine v. Collins, Mr. Justice Harris, Production of Documents, production of pre accident records

Comments (46)

  • I simply want to tell you that I am new to blogging and site-building and truly loved you’re website. Likely I’m likely to bookmark your blog post . You definitely come with fabulous article content. Kudos for sharing your website page.

  • Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I am impressed! Extremely useful info specifically the last part 🙂 I care for such info much. I was looking for this certain info for a very long time. Thank you and good luck.

  • Yet another thing I would like to talk about is that as opposed to trying to fit all your online degree programs on days and nights that you complete work (since the majority people are tired when they go back home), try to have most of your lessons on the weekends and only one or two courses in weekdays, even if it means taking some time away from your weekend break. This is really good because on the weekends, you will be more rested and also concentrated with school work. Thanks alot : ) for the different points I have mastered from your website.

  • Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wanted to say that I’ve truly enjoyed browsing your blog posts. After all I’ll be subscribing to your rss feed and I hope you write again very soon!

  • What i don’t realize is in reality how you’re no longer really a lot more well-liked than you may be now. You’re so intelligent. You recognize thus considerably in relation to this subject, produced me individually believe it from numerous varied angles. Its like men and women are not involved until it’s one thing to do with Woman gaga! Your personal stuffs outstanding. All the time deal with it up!

  • I am also commenting to make you be aware of of the terrific discovery our princess obtained going through the blog. She figured out too many pieces, with the inclusion of what it’s like to have a great coaching style to have other people smoothly know just exactly certain complicated subject matter. You actually did more than my expectations. Many thanks for presenting these essential, healthy, explanatory and also cool tips about this topic to Evelyn.

  • magnificent post, very informative. I wonder why the other experts of this sector don’t notice this. You must continue your writing. I am sure, you have a great readers’ base already!

  • Heya! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any problems with hackers? My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing months of hard work due to no data backup. Do you have any solutions to protect against hackers?

  • I have recently started a web site, the info you provide on this website has helped me tremendously. Thank you for all of your time & work. “Marriage love, honor, and negotiate.” by Joe Moore.

  • Greetings! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a collection of volunteers and starting a new project in a community in the same niche. Your blog provided us valuable information to work on. You have done a extraordinary job!

  • Greetings! This is my 1st comment here so I just wanted to give a quick shout out and tell you I truly enjoy reading your articles. Can you suggest any other blogs/websites/forums that deal with the same topics? Thanks for your time!

  • After study a few of the blog posts in your website now, and I actually like your method of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website list and will likely be checking back soon. Pls try my web page as nicely and let me know what you think.

  • I realized more interesting things on this weight-loss issue. 1 issue is a good nutrition is vital whenever dieting. A massive reduction in bad foods, sugary meals, fried foods, sweet foods, beef, and white flour products may perhaps be necessary. Retaining wastes parasites, and contaminants may prevent targets for losing weight. While a number of drugs in the short term solve the problem, the terrible side effects are usually not worth it, and they also never supply more than a short-lived solution. It’s a known idea that 95 of diet plans fail. Thank you for sharing your notions on this weblog.

  • I conceive this web site has got some very great info for everyone. “He who has not looked on Sorrow will never see Joy.” by Kahlil Gibran.

  • I was curious if you ever thought of changing the layout of your website? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of text for only having 1 or two pictures. Maybe you could space it out better?

  • Thank you, I’ve recently been looking for information approximately this topic for a while and yours is the best I’ve discovered so far. However, what concerning the bottom line? Are you sure about the supply?

  • I like the valuable information you provide in your articles. I’ll bookmark your blog and check again here frequently. I am quite certain I’ll learn many new stuff right here! Best of luck for the next!

  • You actually make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this matter to be really something which I think I would never understand. It seems too complicated and extremely broad for me. I’m looking forward for your next post, I’ll try to get the hang of it!

  • The following time I learn a weblog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as a lot as this one. I imply, I do know it was my option to read, however I truly thought youd have one thing attention-grabbing to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you might repair when you werent too busy searching for attention.

  • I have not checked in here for some time since I thought it was getting boring, but the last several posts are great quality so I guess I will add you back to my everyday bloglist. You deserve it my friend 🙂

  • I¡¦m not sure the place you are getting your information, however good topic. I needs to spend a while finding out much more or working out more. Thanks for magnificent information I was on the lookout for this info for my mission.

  • One thing I want to discuss is that weightloss system fast can be performed by the appropriate diet and exercise. An individual’s size not only affects the look, but also the entire quality of life. Self-esteem, depression, health risks, along with physical capabilities are impacted in extra weight. It is possible to make everything right and still gain. Should this happen, a problem may be the root cause. While a lot food instead of enough exercise are usually accountable, common health concerns and widespread prescriptions may greatly increase size. I am grateful for your post right here.

  • Hola! I’ve been reading your website for a long time now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Austin Tx! Just wanted to say keep up the great work!

  • Thank you for every other informative site. The place else may I get that kind of info written in such an ideal method? I’ve a project that I am just now running on, and I’ve been on the glance out for such information.

  • whoah this weblog is great i love studying your articles. Keep up the good work! You realize, many people are looking around for this information, you can help them greatly.

  • Thank you, I’ve just been looking for information about this subject for ages and yours is the best I’ve found out so far. But, what concerning the conclusion? Are you positive concerning the supply?

  • Hello my loved one! I want to say that this post is amazing, great written and come with approximately all significant infos. I would like to look extra posts like this .

  • you’re actually a just right webmaster. The website loading speed is amazing. It seems that you’re doing any unique trick. Furthermore, The contents are masterwork. you have done a excellent activity on this topic!

  • Absolutely indited articles, thank you for selective information. “He who establishes his argument by noise and command shows that his reason is weak.” by Michel de Montaigne.

  • I intended to draft you this bit of remark in order to give many thanks as before about the pleasing views you’ve featured on this page. This is certainly generous of people like you giving unhampered exactly what a lot of folks could have advertised for an e book to help make some cash for themselves, primarily considering that you might have done it in the event you wanted. The guidelines also acted to provide a good way to be aware that most people have similar passion similar to mine to grasp more in regard to this condition. I am sure there are some more enjoyable periods in the future for individuals that check out your site.

  • Hey there! This is kind of off topic but I need some guidance from an established blog. Is it very hard to set up your own blog? I’m not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty quick. I’m thinking about creating my own but I’m not sure where to start. Do you have any tips or suggestions? Appreciate it

  • Oh my goodness! an amazing article dude. Thanks Nevertheless I am experiencing issue with ur rss . Don’t know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anyone getting an identical rss drawback? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Thnkx

  • excellent put up, very informative. I’m wondering why the other experts of this sector don’t understand this. You must proceed your writing. I’m sure, you’ve a great readers’ base already!

  • I have been exploring for a little bit for any high quality articles or blog posts on this sort of area . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this site. Reading this info So i’m happy to convey that I have a very good uncanny feeling I discovered exactly what I needed. I most certainly will make sure to don’t forget this web site and give it a glance regularly.

  • I have learned some considerations through your blog post. One other point I would like to mention is that there are several games in the marketplace designed specially for toddler age small children. They consist of pattern recognition, colors, dogs, and models. These normally focus on familiarization instead of memorization. This helps to keep a child engaged without having the experience like they are studying. Thanks

Comments are closed.

Contact

If you would like further information or require assistance, please get in touch.

ERIK
MAGRAKEN

Personal Injury Lawyer

When not writing the BC Injury Law Blog, Erik is the managing partner at MacIsaac & Company, based in Victoria, B.C. He is also involved with combative sports regulatory issues and authors the Combat Sports Law Blog.

“Work hard, be kind and enjoy the ride!”
Erik’s Philosophy

Disclaimer