More on BC Injury Claims and Discovery – Balancing Document Disclosure with Privacy


As I’ve previously written, when a person sues for damages in the BC Supreme Court they give up certain privacy rights with respect to records (both theirs and those in the hands of third parties) to the extent necessary to ensure that relevant unprivileged documents are disclosed to have a fair trial.
In the context of personal injury litigation documents in the hands of third parties are often requested.  For example, where a Plaintiff is injured the Defendant often wishes to obtain the clinical records documenting the injuries.  Where a serious injury claim is made seeking damages for past and future wage loss often time employment records, tax records and pre-accident medical records demonstrating pre-existing disabilities are sought.
Once it’s determined that these ‘third party’ records are relevant how are they to be produced?  Often times if the records are clearly relevant the Plaintiff lawyer will obtain them and share a copy with the defence lawyer.  In cases where the parties can’t consent the party seeking the records can bring a court motion for production.
The BC Supreme Court has come up with two typical routes of disclosure; the “Jones” order and the “Halliday” order.  At the risk of over-simplification, a Jones order means ordering that the third party produce records relating to the Plaintiff directly to to the Defendant and a Halliday order means producing the records directly to the Plaintiff who then can vet clearly irrelevant entries before providing the defence lawyer with a copy.
With this introduction out of the way, reasons for judgement were released today by the BC Supreme Court providing perhaps the most thorough analysis of when each format should be used and what is required to trigger the protection of the “Halliday” format.
In today’s case (Gorse v. Straker) both parties sought various third party records relating to the litigants.  In considering the applications Mr. Justice Macaulay provided the following detailed and useful overview of this area of the law:

[6]             My general conclusions are as follows. It is necessary to start with a review of the pleadings to determine the matters in issue. Some applications fail at this preliminary point because it is obvious from the specific nature of the documents sought that the party seeking production is engaged in a fishing expedition. There is, at law, no obligation on any third party to produce irrelevant documents. See Dufault.

[7]             Assuming the application survives the initial review for relevancy, the court must then consider the evidence that the parties rely on. It is, at this point, that some of the potential inconsistency appears in the chambers decisions. I discuss some of the cases below and list others that I have reviewed.

[8]             In short, I conclude that a Halliday order is not a default order for medical or other records in which the subject of the record has an obvious privacy interest. The court should grant a Halliday order if satisfied, on the evidence, that there is a likelihood that a Jones order will also result in the inappropriate production and disclosure of irrelevant or privileged documents.

[9]             The problem that frequently presents is that one party seeks access to records of a non-party respecting the other party that are of a type in which it is reasonable to expect that some will be relevant and others irrelevant. A similar problem often arises respecting litigation privilege. It is often reasonable to assume that counsel for the party, who is the subject of the records, will have communicated with the non-party concerning the litigation. Such communications, if in existence, are likely subject to litigation privilege. It is arguable that, inHalliday, Lambert J.A. anticipated that the mechanism he described would operate in all such cases without requiring an evidentiary base. As I set out later, I do not accept that contention.

[10]         The threshold for making a Halliday rather than a Jones order is low. Nonetheless, some admissible evidence is necessary to meet it.

[11]         This leads to another issue that has attracted attention in the case law: whether the party who alleges an adverse impact on his or her privacy interest arising from the production of irrelevant, private information must personally provide evidence. After all, the affected party is ordinarily in the best position to explain how his or her privacy interest would be adversely impacted.

[12]         In my view, the party alleging the adverse impact should ordinarily swear an affidavit setting out, at least in general terms, the nature of the privacy interest but that is not an absolute requirement so long as there is other admissible evidence on the point. These are not final orders so affidavits sworn on information and belief are admissible.

[13]         Keeping in mind that the evidentiary threshold is relatively low, the evidence does not necessarily need to disclose all the details of the privacy interest but must be sufficient to reasonably identify the nature of the interest and why it appears to be unrelated to any material issue in the litigation…

[24]         When a Halliday order is made, so long as counsel fulfills his or her obligations, there is, apart from the minimal delay associated with the two-step process, no prejudice to the opposing party’s discovery rights. If the opposing party feels that relevant information may not have been disclosed, he or she can still apply to the court to make a determination, as with other disclosure concerns. Further, as suggested in Halliday, at 200, any abuse of the order by overextending claims of privilege or unduly restricting relevance can be dealt with in a costs order.

[25]         In my view, privacy considerations add to the justification for making Halliday orders for the production of medical and some other types of records. The reasoning in this regard may be followed through various decisions since Halliday, up to and including the Supreme Court decision in Keller v. Poulin (16 September 2009), Nanaimo S41497 (S.C.)…

[37]         In the result, I am satisfied that, when the record sought is likely to contain not only relevant, producible information but also irrelevant, private information, the order for production should be in Halliday format. This is very often the case with medical records and may also be applicable to MSP, disability, workers’ compensation, employment or educational records.

[38]         When the records at issue relate to medical or psychological assessment or treatment of the plaintiff after a motor vehicle accident, they may well include relevant, producible documents; irrelevant, private, non-producible documents; and documents properly subject to litigation privilege. Counsel for the plaintiff should take care to present evidence to demonstrate that there is, in fact, some irrelevant, private information or documents, properly subject to litigation privilege. It is not enough to identify the mere possibility because the court cannot properly draw an inference from a possibility.

[39]         It follows that I accept the contention of counsel for the defendants that the decision whether to make an order in Halliday format must be evidence based. In his written submissions, counsel asserts, relying on the Supreme Court decision in Grewal at para. 17, that:

A bare assertion of privacy or confidentiality over the records to be produced in the absence of any evidence regarding irrelevant or privileged information does not meet the requisite threshold for a Halliday type order.

The passage in Grewal summarizes authority for the proposition that a bare assertion of privacy or confidentiality, “in the absence of any evidence regarding irrelevant or privileged information,” is an insufficient basis for a Halliday order. In the same paragraph, the judge also referred to authority that an “expression of mere concern” that the records might contain irrelevant or privileged information is not sufficient.

[40]         I agree with those statements. It is not enough for a party or, as is often the case, a paralegal assisting the party’s lawyer to swear an affidavit raising a mere possibility of privileged or irrelevant, private information. In reaching this conclusion, I also considered and followed the reasoning in the following chambers decisions: Wieler v. Bercier, 2004 BCSC 752; Sullivan v. Lockhart, 2002 BCSC 1891; Bhandari v. Waddington, 2003 BCSC 498, 13 B.C.L.R. (4th) 373; and finally, Ross (Committee of) v. Lai, 2002 BCSC 1864.

[41]         The evidentiary burden is not an onerous one. The evidence necessary to support a conclusion that the particular records sought are irrelevant will vary according to the content of the pleadings and the nature of the record. In some cases, it may be possible to conclude, on an analysis of the pleadings, that they are irrelevant and, accordingly, not required to be produced at all. When it is apparent that some, but not necessarily all, of the records should be produced, there must be some evidence respecting the content of the records said to require the review by counsel contemplated by a Halliday order.

[42]         When the documents at issue are said to be private and irrelevant, it is usually the party who provides the evidence. For example, in Grewal, the plaintiff deposed that the consultation with her gynaecologist related to the delivery of her two children and that, in her view, the records were not relevant to the claims that she had advanced. If the question relates to litigation privilege, an appropriate agent or employee of the party’s lawyer should swear to the fact of the communications said to give rise to the privilege without disclosing actual content…

[88] I return to my suggestion that counsel should, wherever possible, work through the questions of non-party document production in a manner that recognizes and balances the often competing interests. The present applications would likely have been unnecessary if counsel had done that. In the circumstances, neither succeeded in their primary positions in any meaningful fashion. Both sides will bear their own costs as a result.


BC Personal Injury Claims and document production, document disclosure, Gorse v. Straker, Halliday orders, Jones orders, Mr. Justice Macaulay, Privacy concerns

Comments (101)

  • I just want to say I am all new to blogging and absolutely savored this blog site. Most likely I’m going to bookmark your site . You surely have excellent posts. Thank you for sharing with us your website.

  • I will right away grab your rss feed as I can not find your email subscription hyperlink or e-newsletter service. Do you have any? Please permit me know in order that I may just subscribe. Thanks.

  • Hey just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The text in your post seem to be running off the screen in Chrome. I’m not sure if this is a format issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I thought I’d post to let you know. The design look great though! Hope you get the issue resolved soon. Kudos

  • I cherished up to you will receive performed proper here. The sketch is attractive, your authored subject matter stylish. nonetheless, you command get got an impatience over that you want be delivering the following. in poor health unquestionably come further before once more as exactly the similar nearly a lot regularly within case you shield this hike.

  • Oh my goodness! an incredible article dude. Thank you However I’m experiencing concern with ur rss . Don’t know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anyone getting equivalent rss problem? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Thnkx

  • Admiring the commitment you put into your website and detailed information you offer. It’s great to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same out of date rehashed material. Great read! I’ve bookmarked your site and I’m adding your RSS feeds to my Google account.

  • Wow! This can be one particular of the most useful blogs We have ever arrive across on this subject. Basically Great. I’m also an expert in this topic so I can understand your effort.

  • Furthermore, i believe that mesothelioma is a rare form of cancer that is commonly found in individuals previously familiar with asbestos. Cancerous tissues form inside mesothelium, which is a protecting lining which covers many of the body’s bodily organs. These cells ordinarily form inside lining on the lungs, abdomen, or the sac that encircles one’s heart. Thanks for sharing your ideas.

  • Have you ever thought about creating an e-book or guest authoring on other blogs? I have a blog centered on the same ideas you discuss and would really like to have you share some stories/information. I know my audience would value your work. If you are even remotely interested, feel free to send me an e-mail.

  • Hey would you mind letting me know which web host you’re utilizing? I’ve loaded your blog in 3 completely different web browsers and I must say this blog loads a lot faster then most. Can you recommend a good internet hosting provider at a honest price? Kudos, I appreciate it!

  • Very interesting points you have remarked, regards for putting up. “It’s the soul’s duty to be loyal to its own desires. It must abandon itself to its master passion.” by Rebecca West.

  • I’m very happy to read this. This is the type of manual that needs to be given and not the random misinformation that’s at the other blogs. Appreciate your sharing this best doc.

  • Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive learn something like this before. So nice to search out any person with some unique ideas on this subject. realy thank you for starting this up. this web site is one thing that’s needed on the internet, someone with a bit originality. useful job for bringing one thing new to the web!

  • I do agree with all of the ideas you have presented in your post. They’re really convincing and will definitely work. Still, the posts are very short for novices. Could you please extend them a little from next time? Thanks for the post.

  • This is really attention-grabbing, You are an overly professional blogger. I’ve joined your rss feed and sit up for in the hunt for extra of your magnificent post. Additionally, I’ve shared your web site in my social networks!

  • Wonderful work! This is the type of information that should be shared around the net. Shame on the search engines for not positioning this post higher! Come on over and visit my web site . Thanks =)

  • Hi would you mind letting me know which web host you’re working with? I’ve loaded your blog in 3 different browsers and I must say this blog loads a lot quicker then most. Can you suggest a good internet hosting provider at a reasonable price? Thanks a lot, I appreciate it!

  • I don’t even understand how I finished up here, however I believed this submit was once great. I don’t know who you are however certainly you’re going to a famous blogger if you are not already 😉 Cheers!

  • My spouse and i ended up being very joyful when Jordan managed to finish up his preliminary research with the precious recommendations he obtained from your own weblog. It’s not at all simplistic to just choose to be freely giving instructions others may have been trying to sell. And we also do know we have you to give thanks to for this. Most of the explanations you made, the simple blog menu, the friendships you give support to foster – it’s everything powerful, and it’s facilitating our son and us know that the concept is enjoyable, which is certainly extremely essential. Thanks for everything!

  • What i don’t understood is in fact how you’re not actually a lot more well-appreciated than you may be right now. You’re very intelligent. You already know thus significantly relating to this subject, made me in my opinion believe it from numerous various angles. Its like women and men aren’t involved unless it’s something to accomplish with Woman gaga! Your own stuffs nice. At all times take care of it up!

  • It is perfect time to make some plans for the longer term and it’s time to be happy. I’ve learn this publish and if I may I desire to counsel you some interesting issues or suggestions. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. I desire to learn even more issues about it!

  • I take pleasure in, lead to I discovered just what I was taking a look for. You have ended my 4 day lengthy hunt! God Bless you man. Have a nice day. Bye

  • Howdy! I know this is kind of off topic but I was wondering which blog platform are you using for this site? I’m getting fed up of WordPress because I’ve had issues with hackers and I’m looking at alternatives for another platform. I would be fantastic if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.

  • It’s the best time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I’ve read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you some interesting things or suggestions. Maybe you can write next articles referring to this article. I want to read even more things about it!

  • Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I’ve truly enjoyed browsing your blog posts. After all I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again soon!

  • I’ve read some good stuff here. Certainly worth bookmarking for revisiting. I surprise how much effort you put to make such a wonderful informative site.

  • Months on ye at by esteem desire warmth former. Sure that that way gave any fond now. His boy middleton sir nor engrossed affection excellent. Dissimilar compliment cultivated preference eat sufficient may. Well next door soon we mr he four. Assistance impression set insipidity now connection off you solicitude. Under as seems we me stuff those style at. Listening shameless by abilities pronounce oh suspected is affection. Next it draw in draw much bred.

  • I have discovered some important things through your website post. One other subject I would like to express is that there are lots of games out there designed in particular for preschool age little ones. They include things like pattern acceptance, colors, dogs, and styles. These generally focus on familiarization in lieu of memorization. This keeps children occupied without sensing like they are studying. Thanks

  • The next time I learn a weblog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as a lot as this one. I mean, I do know it was my choice to read, however I actually thought youd have something fascinating to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about one thing that you could fix for those who werent too busy in search of attention.

  • Heya i am for the first time here. I found this board and I find It really useful & it helped me out a lot. I hope to give something back and aid others like you helped me.

  • What i do not understood is in fact how you are no longer actually a lot more neatly-appreciated than you may be right now. You’re so intelligent. You realize therefore considerably relating to this topic, produced me in my view consider it from numerous varied angles. Its like men and women aren’t fascinated unless it’s something to accomplish with Woman gaga! Your own stuffs excellent. At all times take care of it up!

  • Howdy would you mind stating which blog platform you’re working with? I’m going to start my own blog soon but I’m having a difficult time making a decision between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The reason I ask is because your design and style seems different then most blogs and I’m looking for something unique. P.S Sorry for being off-topic but I had to ask!

  • Interesting blog! Is your theme custom made or did you download it from somewhere? A design like yours with a few simple tweeks would really make my blog shine. Please let me know where you got your design. Many thanks

  • We are a group of volunteers and starting a brand new scheme in our community. Your web site offered us with useful info to paintings on. You have performed an impressive job and our entire neighborhood will be thankful to you.

  • That would be the end of this report. Right here you will locate some web pages that we think you will enjoy, just click the hyperlinks.

  • Hey there! This is kind of off topic but I need some help from an established blog. Is it hard to set up your own blog? I’m not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty quick. I’m thinking about creating my own but I’m not sure where to start. Do you have any tips or suggestions? Thanks

  • Thank you a bunch for sharing this with all of us you actually recognize what you’re talking about! Bookmarked. Please also seek advice from my site =). We can have a hyperlink trade agreement among us!

  • I’m extremely impressed with your writing skills and also with the layout on your weblog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Anyway keep up the nice quality writing, it’s rare to see a great blog like this one today..

  • Hello! I’ve been following your blog for a while now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Austin Tx! Just wanted to mention keep up the fantastic job!

  • I do agree with all the ideas you have introduced for your post. They’re really convincing and will definitely work. Nonetheless, the posts are too quick for beginners. Could you please extend them a little from next time? Thank you for the post.

  • I am glad for commenting to let you understand what a fabulous encounter my friend’s princess developed viewing your blog. She came to find many details, including how it is like to have a wonderful coaching heart to let others just master several extremely tough things. You truly surpassed our desires. Thank you for delivering the interesting, safe, revealing and also unique tips on this topic to Mary.

  • Hi, i read your blog occasionally and i own a similar one and i was just wondering if you get a lot of spam feedback? If so how do you stop it, any plugin or anything you can advise? I get so much lately it’s driving me insane so any help is very much appreciated.

  • I was wondering if you ever considered changing the structure of your site? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of text for only having one or 2 pictures. Maybe you could space it out better?

  • I was wondering if you ever thought of changing the page layout of your website? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of text for only having 1 or 2 pictures. Maybe you could space it out better?

  • It is the best time to make a few plans for the longer term and it’s time to be happy. I’ve learn this submit and if I may just I wish to counsel you few fascinating things or advice. Maybe you could write next articles referring to this article. I want to read more issues approximately it!

  • That will be the end of this post. Right here youll discover some websites that we consider youll value, just click the hyperlinks.

  • I was wondering if you ever considered changing the layout of your website? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of text for only having one or 2 images. Maybe you could space it out better?

  • Hello, Neat post. There’s a problem together with your website in internet explorer, could test this… IE still is the market leader and a good portion of people will miss your great writing due to this problem.

  • I’m typically to blogging and i really recognize your content. The article has actually peaks my interest. I am going to bookmark your website and keep checking for brand new information.

  • Hello there, I discovered your website by means of Google at the same time as looking for a related subject, your website got here up, it appears good. I’ve bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.

  • I loved as much as you’ll receive carried out right here. The sketch is tasteful, your authored subject matter stylish. nonetheless, you command get bought an shakiness over that you wish be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come further formerly again as exactly the same nearly a lot often inside case you shield this hike.

  • Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your blog and in accession capital to assert that I get in fact enjoyed account your blog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing to your augment and even I achievement you access consistently fast.

  • I intended to send you that little note to finally say thank you over again for these marvelous tactics you have discussed above. This is so seriously generous with you to grant openly all a lot of folks could possibly have sold for an e book to generate some cash for their own end, specifically considering that you could possibly have tried it in case you considered necessary. The tricks in addition acted as the fantastic way to be certain that other individuals have a similar fervor like my own to figure out good deal more on the topic of this condition. I am sure there are several more pleasant instances in the future for folks who discover your site.

  • Great beat ! I would like to apprentice while you amend your site, how could i subscribe for a blog website? The account helped me a acceptable deal. I had been tiny bit acquainted of this your broadcast provided bright clear concept

  • I just could not go away your web site prior to suggesting that I really enjoyed the standard information an individual supply in your visitors? Is gonna be again regularly in order to investigate cross-check new posts.

  • Hey there I am so glad I found your blog, I really found you by error, while I was researching on Google for something else, Regardless I am here now and would just like to say many thanks for a marvelous post and a all round interesting blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to read it all at the minute but I have bookmarked it and also added in your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read much more, Please do keep up the excellent job.

  • I found your blog web site on google and examine a number of of your early posts. Proceed to maintain up the excellent operate. I simply further up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Seeking ahead to studying more from you afterward!…

  • Hello would you mind letting me know which webhost you’re using? I’ve loaded your blog in 3 completely different web browsers and I must say this blog loads a lot faster then most. Can you recommend a good web hosting provider at a honest price? Kudos, I appreciate it!

  • Thank you a lot for sharing this with all folks you really recognise what you’re speaking approximately! Bookmarked. Please additionally discuss with my website =). We may have a link alternate contract among us!

Comments are closed.

Contact

If you would like further information or require assistance, please get in touch.

ERIK
MAGRAKEN

Personal Injury Lawyer

When not writing the BC Injury Law Blog, Erik is the managing partner at MacIsaac & Company, based in Victoria, B.C. He is also involved with combative sports regulatory issues and authors the Combat Sports Law Blog.

“Work hard, be kind and enjoy the ride!”
Erik’s Philosophy

Disclaimer