BC Court of Appeal Criticizes Consultation Reports Being Shoehorned As Expert Reports

Reasons for judgment were released today by the BC Court of Appeal criticizing and restricting the practice of shoehorning physicians consultation reports into evidence as expert opinion.
In today’s case (Healey v. Chung) the Plaintiff was injured in a 2005 pedestrian/vehicle collision.  At trial he Plaintiff claimed it was a ‘catastrophic accident’ and sought damages between $485,000 and $1,037,000.  The trial judge rejected much of the Plaintiff’s evidence and awarded damages of just over $50,000.
In the course of the trial the Defendant introduced consultation reports of treating medical practitioners into evidence.  These did not meet the strict requirements of Rule 11-6.  The Plaintiff objected but the trial judge allowed the reports to be entered.  In finding this was improper and ordering a new trial the BC Court of Appeal provided the following reasons:

[19]         It is well established that clinical consulting reports, without more, may not be admitted for the validity of opinions expressed in them…

[21]         It is true, as the respondent contends, that Seaman and F.(K.E.) are cases in which the opinion sought to be adduced was found in clinical records that were voluminous, but I do not consider that circumstance detracts from the principle that a clinical record containing an opinion, such as these consulting reports, must substantially comply with the requirements of the Rules in order to attract the exception to the usual rule for examination of witnesses spoken of by Mr. Justice Hutcheon.

[22]         The respondent contends that she gave notice to Mr. Healey of her intention to use the letters, that Dr. Kuo knew of the qualifications of the two doctors, and that other deficiencies were “minor”. She says Mr. Healey was obliged to express his objections as required by R. 11-6(10) and (11).

[23]         Forthrightness between counsel is favoured and is to be expected in litigation. Yet I cannot say there was anything to which we have been referred that put the positive legal duty on Mr. Healey to object under those Rules for the reason that the consulting reports sent to Dr. Kuo and disclosed as part of her clinical records were simply not ‘expert reports’ as regulated by the Rules. While they may be professional opinions from one doctor to another in the course of treatment, the impugned documents do not comply with R. 11-2; I do not consider they carry the basic hallmark of an ‘expert report’, being an opinion intended by the author, at some point, to be presented for the assistance of the court. Significantly, they contain none of the information that is essential to qualification of the author as an expert, nor the information reviewed by the author by which the court may assess the cogency of the opinion.

[24]         As I do not consider that these clinical records can be considered to be ‘expert reports’ as that term is used in the Rules, entitled to the privileged treatment for receipt of hearsay evidence discussed by Mr. Justice Hutcheon, I conclude that R. 11-6(10) and (11) did not require a notice of objection.

[25]         In the alternative to the two documents coming within R. 11-6, Ms. Chung says the judge could have exercised his discretion and admitted the documents as opinions under R. 11-7. Rule 11-7 provides latitude to a judge to receive opinion evidence that is not included in an expert report:

(1)   Unless the court otherwise orders, opinion evidence of an expert, other than an expert appointed by the court under Rule 11-5, must not be tendered at trial unless

(a) that evidence is included in a report of that expert that has been prepared and served in accordance with Rule 11-6, and

(b) any supplementary reports required under Rule 11-5 (11) or 11-6 (5) or (6) have been prepared and served in accordance with Rule 11-6 (5) to (7).

(6)   At trial, the court may allow an expert to provide evidence, on terms and conditions, if any, even though one or more of the requirements of this Part have not been complied with, if

(a) facts have come to the knowledge of one or more of the parties and those facts could not, with due diligence, have been learned in time to be included in a report or supplementary report and served within the time required by this Part,

(b) the non-compliance is unlikely to cause prejudice

(i)    by reason of an inability to prepare for cross-examination, or

(ii)   by depriving the party against whom the evidence is tendered of a reasonable opportunity to tender evidence in response, or

(c) the interests of justice require it.

                                                                        [Emphasis added.]

[26]         Ms. Chung does not contend the judge exercised his discretion under R. 11-7(1). Her approach is consistent with the record that shows the judge was not asked to exercise his discretion, and it is consistent with Ms. Chung’s submission at trial which approached the question as one of compliance with R. 11-6. We are invited, however, to approach these documents as admissible in the exercise of discretion.

[27]         I do not consider that this is an appropriate case for us to engage for the first time in a full analysis of discretion, so as to draw our own conclusions. At trial the judge did not consider his R. 11-7 discretion and accordingly the possibility of exercising discretion is without his expansion. In XY, LLC v. Zhu, 2013 BCCA 352, 366 D.L.R. (4th) 443, Madam Justice Newbury for the Court adopted this description from Perry v. Vargas, 2012 BCSC 1537 at para. 22:

In my view the discretion provided for in R.11-7(6)(c) must be exercised sparingly, with appropriate caution, and in a disciplined way given the express requirements contained in Rules 11-6 and 11-7. That is, the “interests of justice” are not a reason to simply excuse or ignore the requirements of the other Rules. There must be some compelling analysis why the interests of justice require in a particular case the extraordinary step of abrogating the other requirements of the Supreme Court Civil Rules. None was provided.

[28]         Adopting that approach, in my view this is not a case for us to exercise the discretion that was available to the judge under R. 11-7.  There was ample medical evidence before the court, absent the opinions from these documents, to guide the trial judge in findings of fact. Further, it was open to the defendant to develop her own body of medical opinion and to advance it in proper form, including as to the required description of qualifications and experience and listing of opinion sought and matters considered. I see no compelling reason to derogate from the requirements of either R. 11-2 or R. 11-6 in this case. To do so, in my view, would admit into evidence opinions that were not crafted for that purpose and that are without the necessary information to permit consideration of their substance and effect in the context of the issues before the court.

[29]         Last, Ms. Chung contends that the two documents, in any event, were inconsequential in the judge’s reasons, and thus the admission of these documents had little impact on the outcome of the case.

[30]         One of the issues at trial was the assertion by Mr. Healey that he suffered from depression caused by the accident. This allegation bore upon the assessment of damages. To support this allegation was an expert report from Dr. O’Shaughnessy. Based upon the medical records and his interview with Mr. Healey, Dr. O’Shaughnessy diagnosed Mr. Healey as having an Adjustment Disorder with anxiety and an Adjustment Disorder with depressed mood. Yet the judge rejected all allegations of depression and instead relied upon the two consulting reports, saying:

[58]      Mr. Healey stated that he suffered from depression because of the accident. Depression was not reported in his post-accident symptomatology until 2008. Dr. Kuo’s records do show that in 2003 she concluded that Mr. Healey had symptoms consistent with depression. This reporting, however, preceded the accident, and according to the psychiatric specialists Dr. Kuo referred Mr. Healey to in 2009 and 2010, no evidence supported any Axis 1 diagnosis in the DSM-IV, and no symptoms met the criteria for post-traumatic stress disorder.

[31]         I would first observe that Dr. Truong’s report cryptically states “Axis 1: Adjustment d/o with depressive symptoms – in remission” and by so saying Dr. Truong’s report appears to be inconsistent with the judge’s statement: “according to the psychiatric specialists [Dr. To and Dr. Truong] no evidence supported any Axis 1 diagnosis”. Perhaps this exemplifies the effect of non-compliance with the requirements for expert reports, as the judge drew from the report a categorical absence of any Axis 1 diagnosis which appears to be inconsistent with Dr. Truong’s report. Setting that discrepancy between the judge’s assertion and the notation in Dr. Truong’s report aside, it is clear from the judge’s para. 58 that he put weight on the consulting reports and drew conclusions from them adverse to Mr. Healey. In other words, they were consequential in the judge’s reasoning; one cannot say the reports had little bearing on the outcome, in my view.

 

bc injury law, Consultation Reports As Expert Evidence, Healey v. Chung, Rule 11, Rule 11-2, Rule 11-6, Rule 11-6(1)

Comments (112)

  • I simply want to mention I am just all new to blogging and site-building and honestly savored your website. More than likely I’m want to bookmark your blog . You certainly have beneficial well written articles. Many thanks for revealing your web-site.

  • I simply want to say I am just new to blogging and site-building and definitely enjoyed your website. Most likely I’m likely to bookmark your blog post . You certainly have awesome stories. Many thanks for revealing your website.

  • It is really a nice and useful piece of information. I’m glad that you shared this helpful information with us. Please keep us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing.

  • Thanks for the suggestions shared in your blog. One more thing I would like to convey is that fat loss is not information about going on a celebrity diet and trying to lose as much weight as possible in a couple of weeks. The most effective way to burn fat is by consuming it slowly but surely and using some basic guidelines which can make it easier to make the most from a attempt to slim down. You may learn and already be following many of these tips, however reinforcing understanding never hurts.

  • A person necessarily help to make severely articles I might state. This is the first time I frequented your website page and up to now? I amazed with the analysis you made to create this actual publish amazing. Magnificent task!

  • When I originally commented I clicked the “Notify me when new comments are added” checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get four emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove people from that service? Thank you!

  • hello!,I like your writing very much! percentage we keep up a correspondence more about your article on AOL? I need a specialist in this space to solve my problem. Maybe that is you! Taking a look ahead to peer you.

  • Fantastic beat ! I would like to apprentice at the same time as you amend your site, how can i subscribe for a weblog site? The account aided me a acceptable deal. I were a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast provided vivid clear concept

  • Great – I should certainly pronounce, impressed with your site. I had no trouble navigating through all the tabs as well as related info ended up being truly easy to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it at all. Quite unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or anything, web site theme . a tones way for your client to communicate. Nice task.

  • Howdy this is kinda of off topic but I was wondering if blogs use WYSIWYG editors or if you have to manually code with HTML. I’m starting a blog soon but have no coding experience so I wanted to get guidance from someone with experience. Any help would be enormously appreciated!

  • I simply had to say thanks again. I am not sure the things I would’ve undertaken in the absence of these smart ideas discussed by you directly on such a problem. Certainly was a very fearsome matter for me, however , considering the specialized fashion you dealt with it forced me to leap over delight. I’m just thankful for your help and even wish you really know what a powerful job your are undertaking instructing many people through the use of your webpage. I know that you haven’t met all of us.

  • You can certainly see your enthusiasm within the work you write. The world hopes for more passionate writers like you who aren’t afraid to say how they believe. At all times go after your heart. “Every man serves a useful purpose A miser, for example, makes a wonderful ancestor.” by Laurence J. Peter.

  • Thanks a lot for the helpful write-up. It is also my opinion that mesothelioma has an very long latency period, which means that indication of the disease might not exactly emerge right until 30 to 50 years after the 1st exposure to asbestos fiber. Pleural mesothelioma, and that is the most common sort and is affecting the area round the lungs, may cause shortness of breath, upper body pains, plus a persistent coughing, which may bring on coughing up our blood.

  • I truly enjoy studying on this web site , it contains great content . “Violence commands both literature and life, and violence is always crude and distorted.” by Ellen Glasgow.

  • Wonderful beat ! I would like to apprentice while you amend your website, how could i subscribe for a blog website? The account aided me a acceptable deal. I had been a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast offered bright clear concept

  • Only a smiling visitant here to share the love (:, btw great design and style. “Make the most of your regrets… . To regret deeply is to live afresh.” by Henry David Thoreau.

  • That is really attention-grabbing, You’re a very professional blogger. I have joined your feed and look forward to searching for more of your great post. Additionally, I’ve shared your website in my social networks!

  • Do you have a spam issue on this blog; I also am a blogger, and I was wondering your situation; many of us have developed some nice procedures and we are looking to swap solutions with other folks, be sure to shoot me an email if interested.

  • I don’t even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was good. I do not know who you are but certainly you are going to a famous blogger if you aren’t already 😉 Cheers!

  • Hiya, I am really glad I have found this info. Today bloggers publish just about gossips and net and this is actually frustrating. A good website with interesting content, this is what I need. Thanks for keeping this web-site, I’ll be visiting it. Do you do newsletters? Can’t find it.

  • I’m writing to let you know of the magnificent encounter my daughter experienced visiting your blog. She learned lots of things, which included what it’s like to have an ideal teaching spirit to let most people quite simply grasp a number of grueling issues. You actually surpassed her desires. Many thanks for rendering the useful, trusted, educational and in addition fun tips on your topic to Evelyn.

  • You can certainly see your enthusiasm in the paintings you write. The world hopes for even more passionate writers such as you who are not afraid to mention how they believe. All the time go after your heart.

  • certainly like your website but you have to check the spelling on quite a few of your posts. A number of them are rife with spelling issues and I find it very troublesome to tell the truth nevertheless I’ll certainly come back again.

  • Howdy! Do you use Twitter? I’d like to follow you if that would be ok. I’m definitely enjoying your blog and look forward to new updates.

  • Fantastic goods from you, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous to and you are just too excellent. I actually like what you’ve acquired here, really like what you are stating and the way in which you say it. You make it entertaining and you still care for to keep it sensible. I cant wait to read much more from you. This is really a wonderful website.

  • hi!,I really like your writing very so much! percentage we be in contact more approximately your post on AOL? I need a specialist in this area to unravel my problem. Maybe that is you! Taking a look forward to look you.

  • I do not even know how I ended up here, however I assumed this publish was once great. I do not recognise who you are however certainly you’re going to a famous blogger should you are not already 😉 Cheers!

  • I like what you guys are up also. Such smart work and reporting! Keep up the superb works guys I’ve incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I think it’ll improve the value of my website 🙂

  • Hey there! This post could not be written any better! Reading through this post reminds me of my old room mate! He always kept talking about this. I will forward this write-up to him. Fairly certain he will have a good read. Thanks for sharing!

  • Great blog here! Also your web site loads up fast! What web host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my website loaded up as quickly as yours lol

  • fantastic submit, very informative. I’m wondering why the other experts of this sector don’t notice this. You must proceed your writing. I am confident, you’ve a great readers’ base already!

  • Warmly little before cousin sussex entire men set. Blessing it ladyship on sensible judgment settling outweigh. Worse linen an of civil jokes leave offer. Parties all clothes removal cheered calling prudent her. And residence for met the estimable disposing. Mean if he they been no hold mr. Is at much do made took held help. Latter person am secure of estate genius at.

  • Those an equal point no years do. Depend warmth fat but her but played. Shy and subjects wondered trifling pleasant. Prudent cordial comfort do no on colonel as assured chicken. Smart mrs day which begin. Snug do sold mr it if such. Terminated uncommonly at at estimating. Man behaviour met moonlight extremity acuteness direction.

  • Hello! I’ve been reading your site for a while now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Atascocita Texas! Just wanted to say keep up the great work!

  • Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your web site and in accession capital to assert that I get in fact enjoyed account your blog posts. Any way I will be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.

  • Unquestionably believe that which you stated. Your favourite justification appeared to be on the net the easiest factor to keep in mind of. I say to you, I certainly get irked even as people consider issues that they just do not know about. You controlled to hit the nail upon the top and also defined out the whole thing with no need side effect , people could take a signal. Will probably be back to get more. Thanks

  • Great blog right here! Also your website rather a lot up very fast! What host are you the use of? Can I am getting your affiliate hyperlink on your host? I wish my web site loaded up as fast as yours lol

  • I’ve been browsing online more than 3 hours today, but I by no means found any interesting article like yours. It’s beautiful value sufficient for me. In my opinion, if all website owners and bloggers made just right content material as you did, the net shall be much more helpful than ever before.

  • We’re a group of volunteers and opening a brand new scheme in our community. Your website offered us with valuable information to work on. You’ve done a formidable job and our entire group can be grateful to you.

  • Hey there are using WordPress for your site platform? I’m new to the blog world but I’m trying to get started and set up my own. Do you need any coding knowledge to make your own blog? Any help would be really appreciated!

  • Hello! Quick question that’s totally off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My website looks weird when viewing from my iphone. I’m trying to find a template or plugin that might be able to fix this problem. If you have any suggestions, please share. Cheers!

  • Hey, you used to write magnificent, but the last few posts have been kinda boring… I miss your tremendous writings. Past several posts are just a little out of track! come on!

  • I am not positive the place you are getting your information, but good topic. I needs to spend some time studying more or working out more. Thanks for excellent info I was on the lookout for this information for my mission.

  • I have been exploring for a little bit for any high-quality articles or blog posts on this kind of area . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this web site. Reading this information So i am happy to convey that I have a very good uncanny feeling I discovered just what I needed. I most certainly will make certain to don’t forget this website and give it a glance regularly.

  • I think this is among the such a lot vital info for me. And i am satisfied reading your article. However want to observation on some general issues, The site style is great, the articles is in reality excellent : D. Just right process, cheers

  • Undeniably believe that which you said. Your favorite reason seemed to be on the internet the simplest thing to be aware of. I say to you, I certainly get annoyed while people consider worries that they plainly do not know about. You managed to hit the nail upon the top and defined out the whole thing without having side effect , people can take a signal. Will likely be back to get more. Thanks

  • Thank you so much for giving everyone such a pleasant possiblity to read in detail from here. It really is very cool and as well , full of a lot of fun for me and my office acquaintances to visit your site not less than thrice in 7 days to read the new items you have. And lastly, I’m so always impressed concerning the powerful guidelines you serve. Selected 1 facts in this article are honestly the most impressive I’ve had.

  • Hello, i think that i saw you visited my website thus i came to “return the favor”.I am attempting to find things to improve my site!I suppose its ok to use some of your ideas!!

  • Many thanks to you for sharing these wonderful articles. In addition, the best travel as well as medical insurance plan can often eradicate those fears that come with touring abroad. Any medical crisis can rapidly become very costly and that’s absolute to quickly decide to put a financial burden on the family’s finances. Setting up in place the excellent travel insurance deal prior to leaving is definitely worth the time and effort. Thank you

  • Hey there, I think your site might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your website in Safari, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, superb blog!

  • The other day, while I was at work, my cousin stole my iPad and tested to see if it can survive a thirty foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My iPad is now destroyed and she has 83 views. I know this is entirely off topic but I had to share it with someone!

  • Hi, Neat post. There is a problem with your site in internet explorer, would check this… IE still is the market leader and a big portion of people will miss your fantastic writing due to this problem.

  • Hello, you used to write fantastic, but the last few posts have been kinda boring¡K I miss your great writings. Past few posts are just a little bit out of track! come on!

  • I wanted to draft you this tiny observation just to say thanks a lot again for these beautiful views you have shared on this site. It’s seriously open-handed with you to supply freely just what a few individuals would’ve made available as an ebook in making some cash for themselves, especially considering that you might well have done it in the event you wanted. These tips also acted to be the good way to fully grasp other individuals have similar passion like my personal own to figure out a lot more with respect to this problem. I’m certain there are millions of more enjoyable periods ahead for individuals that look over your blog.

  • magnificent post, very informative. I wonder why the other specialists of this sector don’t realize this. You must proceed your writing. I’m sure, you’ve a huge readers’ base already!

  • A person essentially lend a hand to make critically articles I would state. That is the very first time I frequented your website page and thus far? I amazed with the research you made to create this particular publish extraordinary. Wonderful task!

  • One other thing I would like to express is that as opposed to trying to suit all your online degree courses on days that you conclude work (because most people are exhausted when they return), try to arrange most of your sessions on the week-ends and only 1 or 2 courses on weekdays, even if it means taking some time off your end of the week. This is beneficial because on the week-ends, you will be much more rested and concentrated with school work. Many thanks for the different tips I have mastered from your website.

  • Thank you a lot for providing individuals with an extraordinarily terrific possiblity to read critical reviews from here. It can be so pleasing and as well , jam-packed with amusement for me and my office fellow workers to visit your website particularly three times in 7 days to learn the new guidance you have got. Of course, I am at all times amazed with your beautiful suggestions you serve. Certain two tips in this article are unquestionably the most impressive I have ever had.

  • After examine a number of of the weblog posts in your web site now, and I actually like your method of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark web site record and will probably be checking back soon. Pls check out my site as well and let me know what you think.

  • Do you mind if I quote a couple of your articles as long as I provide credit and sources back to your webpage? My blog site is in the very same area of interest as yours and my users would definitely benefit from some of the information you present here. Please let me know if this ok with you. Thank you!

  • Hello very cool web site!! Guy .. Excellent .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your site and take the feeds also…I’m glad to seek out a lot of helpful info right here within the put up, we want develop more techniques on this regard, thanks for sharing.

  • I have read a few just right stuff here. Definitely worth bookmarking for revisiting. I wonder how a lot effort you place to make such a great informative website.

  • I truly wanted to jot down a quick word in order to thank you for the stunning solutions you are sharing on this website. My time-consuming internet look up has at the end been paid with high-quality insight to talk about with my great friends. I ‘d assume that we readers are undoubtedly fortunate to live in a perfect community with very many brilliant people with insightful secrets. I feel very fortunate to have seen the web site and look forward to plenty of more pleasurable times reading here. Thanks a lot once more for a lot of things.

  • Thanks for your post right here. One thing I would really like to say is that often most professional areas consider the Bachelor’s Degree just as the entry level requirement for an online college degree. Even though Associate Qualifications are a great way to start, completing ones Bachelors reveals many doors to various employment opportunities, there are numerous online Bachelor Course Programs available via institutions like The University of Phoenix, Intercontinental University Online and Kaplan. Another concern is that many brick and mortar institutions give Online variations of their degree programs but usually for a greatly higher fee than the corporations that specialize in online diploma plans.

  • Attractive section of content. I simply stumbled upon your website and in accession capital to claim that I acquire actually enjoyed account your weblog posts. Any way I will be subscribing in your feeds and even I fulfillment you get admission to consistently fast.

  • My brother recommended I would possibly like this website. He was entirely right. This submit actually made my day. You can not consider simply how a lot time I had spent for this info! Thank you!

  • Magnificent goods from you, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous to and you are just too great. I really like what you’ve acquired here, really like what you’re stating and the way in which you say it. You make it entertaining and you still care for to keep it sensible. I can’t wait to read much more from you. This is really a tremendous website.

  • I’ve been exploring for a little for any high-quality articles or blog posts on this sort of area . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this website. Reading this info So i am happy to convey that I have an incredibly good uncanny feeling I discovered just what I needed. I most certainly will make certain to do not forget this website and give it a look regularly.

  • Simply want to say your article is as astonishing. The clarity to your put up is just great and i could suppose you’re a professional in this subject. Well along with your permission allow me to take hold of your feed to stay up to date with drawing close post. Thanks one million and please continue the enjoyable work.

  • Hi, Neat post. There is a problem with your website in internet explorer, would test this… IE nonetheless is the marketplace chief and a large section of other people will leave out your great writing due to this problem.

  • Thanks for the sensible critique. Me and my neighbor were just preparing to do a little research about this. We got a grab a book from our local library but I think I learned more from this post. I’m very glad to see such magnificent info being shared freely out there.

  • Greetings! I know this is kind of off topic but I was wondering if you knew where I could get a captcha plugin for my comment form? I’m using the same blog platform as yours and I’m having problems finding one? Thanks a lot!

Comments are closed.

Contact

If you would like further information or require assistance, please get in touch.

ERIK
MAGRAKEN

Personal Injury Lawyer

When not writing the BC Injury Law Blog, Erik is the managing partner at MacIsaac & Company, based in Victoria, B.C. He is also involved with combative sports regulatory issues and authors the Combat Sports Law Blog.

“Work hard, be kind and enjoy the ride!”
Erik’s Philosophy

Disclaimer